Eac System Sizing - Assignment Point
Eac System Sizing
Subject: Engineering | Topics:

Typical EAC System Sizing:

EAC capacity can be sized using different methods. The most common method used by engineers is a building heat balance using manual calculations or a computer program. Summing the heat gains from solar, lights, computers and other office equipment, people and the heat gain from the building envelope will give a heat extraction rate which can be used to size the cooling equipment.


Rigid media is more effective than aspen media, so the discharge temperature will be cooler. This means that less airflow is required to remove the same amount of heat from the building.

The equipment is typically not sized to meet the worst case conditions, but to satisfy the peak loads 98% of the time. The ASHRAE Book of Fundamentals provides an historical base of temperature design values in the .4%, 1%, and 2% (of annual hours) column of their “Climatic Conditions for the United States” table. Some of this design information for selected New Mexico cities is shown in Appendix A. Some EAC manufactures offer free energy analysis and sizing programs that can help the designer estimate the energy and water use with their catalog information.

Wet-bulb Depression

EAC’s are sized based on the wet-bulb temperature. Most people are familiar with a fluid filled thermometer with a bulb on the bottom. This thermometer will measure the “dry-bulb” (or sensible) temperature. Now if we were to put a small fabric sock over the bulb on the bottom, and then wet the sock and move air past it, the evaporative effect will cool the sock and the bulb and decrease the temperature reading on the thermometer column. The value that is read from the column would now represent the “wet-bulb” (or latent) temperature.

Because EAC is not sensible cooling, we cannot state an equipment efficiency factor or Energy Efficiency Ratio (EER) as with refrigerated cooling. Instead, there is a term called “saturation effectiveness” sometimes referred to as evaporative effectiveness, which can be used to predict the performance of EAC’s. See Equation 1: Saturation Effectiveness. This effectiveness is calculated as the ratio of the change in dry-bulb temperature divided by the difference between the outside air dry-bulb and the wet-bulb temperature (or wet-bulb depression). This saturation effectiveness varies with media type and has been tested and measured for different types of EAC’s. Knowing these values it is possible to solve for the EAC discharge temperature T-2, see equation 2. Refer to Appendix A for a complete explanation with examples for this calculation. This equation is shown below.

Equation 1: Saturation Effectiveness (“Efficiency”)

                       (T1 – T2)

SE = 100 X

                             (T1 – T3)


SE = Saturation Effectiveness (per cent)

T1 = Dry—Bulb Temperature of Entering Air

T2 = Dry—Bulb Temperature of Leaving Air

T3 = Wet Bulb Temperature of Entering Air ( Usually the mean coincident wet

          Bulb-MCWB )

Equation 2: Evaporative Cooler Supply Air Temperature

T2 = T1 – (SE X (T2 – T3))

Table 8 below compares the discharge temperature downstream of the evaporative media for different saturation effectiveness for typical conditions in Albuquerque, New Mexico. The effectiveness is also dependent on the air velocity through the evaporative media, which normally range from 400 to 700 feet per minute. A lower velocity results in a higher effectiveness, less fan power as discussed below, and longer media life. A higher velocity results in less residency time between the air and the water, thus decreasing the effectiveness. Velocities over 600 fpm will require mist eliminators to prevent water carryover, and are not recommended. High media face velocities along with insufficient water flow also accelerate mineral buildup.

EAC Effectiveness Comparison


1)       Evaporative Cooler Supply Air Temperature DB-out = DB-in – (Evap. Eff. X (DB-in – WB-in))

2)        Weather Data Source: New Mexico Climate Manual, NMERDI 2-72-4523

Air Velocity Through the Wetted Pad :

Air velocity past the face of the media is an influential factor in EAC design. When the air is slow, the cooling effect is greater, and the air pressure drop is lower. However, the unit is larger and the first cost is greater. If the air is too fast, less cooling will take place and water entrainment into the air stream may occur. Any water buildup in the downstream ductwork can cause water damage and other associated problems. Most manufactures will design their equipment around 500 to 600 fpm face velocity. Mist eliminators can be put into the air stream over 600 fpm to try to catch the mist (also known as carryover), but these devices will use more fan power over the life of the unit. Media velocity is also increased when the buildup of solids in the water is not controlled properly.

“High face velocities also incur higher airflow resistances and require more water flow for uniform wetting. Because evaporation rates may exceed certain strands’ capillary powers to rewet themselves, high velocity in pads frequently causes dry spots, which admit hot air and clog rapidly. Pad clogging is clearly related to local velocity; the lower the general pad velocity, the more slowly and uniformly clogging progresses. Specifically, clogging is the depositing of clinging lime and dust on the pad fibers. It occurs principally where alternating wetting and drying are by turns bringing dissolved minerals and then evaporating the water and precipitating its mineral content. Midway in that drying process, impinging dust is not washed away but adheres permanently with the deposited lime”.

Yardsticks for EAC Sizing:

An accurate sizing method will account for both internal and external building loads. The following yardstick sizing methods can be used to determine a rough sizing estimate for budget assessments, but since they do not take loads into account, they are not recommended for system sizing.

An accepted EAC rough sizing method is based on the number of air changes per hour (AC/hr) to determine the airflow rate based on the heat load and the ambient (local air) wet-bulb temperature. This method is straightforward to use since the air change volume is easily calculated by multiplying the three dimensions of the conditioned space. This AC/hr method should only be used for rooms with an eight to ten foot ceiling height. The wet-bulb temperature referenced in Table 7 can be obtained from weather history tables (i.e.: ASHRAE Fundamentals). A table of dry-bulb temperatures and their mean coincident wet-bulb (MCWB) temperatures are provided for selected New Mexico cities in Appendix A. The capacity of EAC’s is usually given in cubic feet of air per minute (CFM). Therefore, it is possible to use this rough sizing method to determine the airflow capacity necessary to cool the space.

The recommended air change rates for direct EAC’s for different wet-bulb conditions are given in Table 7 below. “Note that these are general air change volumes used. It is not recommended to use less than one air change every 5 minutes for most applications.”

Another more general rule-of-thumb check for EAC system sizing is the quantity of air delivered per unit floor area, or CFM/SF. This value is usually between 1.5 (on low-speed) to 5 CFM/SF depending on the building loads, insulation values, etc. For instance, an aspen pad cooler serving a poorly insulated building with no exterior shading and many internal heat sources would typically use 4+ CFM/SF, while a rigid media cooler serving a well insulated building with large trees on the southwest, few internal heat sources and low occupancy would use 1.5 CFM/SF. More air delivery means larger ducts and more fan energy and may affect the acoustics of the room. If the airflow is insufficient, comfort cannot be maintained. A good design will include a two-speed fan (or a more expensive variable speed fan) so that the maximum air flowrate will only be delivered during peak load periods.

Another method of predicting performance of a direct or indirect EAC is described here. “Apart from using the rough measure of climate zones or the level of humidity, one can predict the effectiveness of EAC for a particular location fairly accurately using the locally prevailing wet-bulb temperatures (WB). Table 9 shows how these are measured. In brief, by adding about 9F to the WB, one knows the effective room temperature that can be reached with EAC. Because the WB varies over seasons and during the course of the day, it does not suffice to use average WB. Rather, one should consider the WB at the time when cooling is most important-for example, around noon.”

Manufacturers Catalog Data

Manufacturers of packaged EAC and combination units will usually show catalog data for several different models of EAC’s. Their unit’s cooling capacities are usually given for sea-level, but a cubic foot of the thinner air in many of the New Mexico mountainous areas can’t hold as many Btu’s as a cubic foot of denser sea-level air. Air density, or altitude effects will also affect a fan’s horse power requirements, duct friction and fan selection. Consult manufacturer’s instructions for derating EAC’s (or refrigerated air units) when the site elevation exceeds 2000 feet. Some manufacturer information is included in Appendix B. Additionally, they will include data such as dimensional, weight, options and electrical. The selection options for EAC features will include:

  • Type. Direct, Indirect, Combination units and media type and thickness. The evaporative  saturation effectiveness is affected by the media type, thickness and air speed through the media.
  • Construction features. These can be related to the length of the warranty period. These features include cabinet materials, method of welding, corrosion inhibiting treatments or coatings, motor speeds, bearing type, pump and distribution system, and fan voltage.
  • Configuration. Options include side or down discharge, damper configuration, filters and heating options. Down discharge models should include a field supplied access door to allow inspection and repair of the duct and water connections located under the unit. The mounting options would include roof curb, skid mount, pad on-grade, etc.
  • Capacity. For EAC’s this is usually stated for sea-level in terms of airflow in CFM, and static pressure in inches of water, for a specific fan size or type and motor horsepower. The static pressure is usually given as the external static pressure (ESP), external to the unit, or it could be shown in total static pressure (TSP) in which case the media pressure drop should be added. An HVAC engineer should calculate the static pressure losses associated with the system ductwork, diffusers, grilles, relief air duct, relief air dampers and louvers. This consultant, typically a mechanical engineer, can also calculate the cooling loads, size the ductwork and apply corrections for altitude.
  • Controls: EAC controls usually consist of a thermostat or manual control switches, and sometimes damper controls and programming schedule. Manual switch control will have a fan on/off, pump on/off, and often fan high/low speed. Division 15 of the Operations to detail the exact order in which components should operate on a project-project specifications or the mechanical drawings should include a Sequence of by-project basis. See the next section on Controls.
  • Thermostat type can be 1) a microprocessor based which usually has a digital display, and uses a battery or a low-voltage transformer, or 2) a 120 volt (referred to as line-voltage) thermostat which is not recommended because of their limited capability, high maintenance requirements and life safety factors associated when electrical arcs are used around flammable gasses. The thermostat will usually turn a supply fan on or off in response to the load, and some will also control two-speed fans. Although not recommended by most media manufacturers, some thermostats will cycle the sump pump on or off (often referred to as the cooler to vent cycle) to help control temperature while maintaining fan operation. The low-voltage microprocessor based thermostat will usually offer additional money saving and comfort improving options. Some of these are the timed shut-off, night and weekend automatic temperature set-back/up, fan hours totaling, and a media pre-wet cycle. Some also control a gas or electric heating section as well.
  • Damper controls for an economizer damper package used for “free” air cooling during the spring and fall. These dampers are also used for closing off the outside air dampers during unoccupied periods are recommended for energy conservation.

Eac System Sizing

Related Engineering Paper: