The main purpose of this report is to get an overall process about the Banking Operation of Uttara Bank Limited and evaluate the contribution of Scheme deposits in total collection of remittance. Other discussion are to identify how to deals third bank payment. Here also discuss on the overall performance of the bank’s UBL to other private banks. Finally justify the extent of the use of Finance in UBL system.
The general objective of the report is….
- To know about the management system of Uttara Bank Limited as a largest corporate bank in the country, its formation, and its functional and financial aspects.
- To identify how to deals third bank payment
- To know detail of overall banking system of Uttara Bank Limited
- To know the important criteria required for the attainment of UBL.
- To make a comparison on GB department in Uttara Bank and other private sector Banks.
- To assess the overall performance of the bank’s UBL to other private banks.
- To justify the extent of the use of Finance in UBL system.
Overview of Uttara bank Ltd
Uttara Bank Limited UBL is a private commercial Bank in Bangladesh. Uttara Bank-one of the largest and oldest private-sector commercial bank in Bangladesh, with years of experience. Adaptation of modern technology both in terms of equipment and banking practice ensures efficient service to clients. 201 branches at home and other more affiliates worldwide create efficient networking. Uttara Bank is a bank that serves both clients and country.
UBL, started the project of seven days assured payment scheme to serve quickly the foreign remittance sender On the other hand, it has achieved the membership of Society for Worldwide international Financial ‘Telecommunication (SWIFT) to accurate the international business and banking activities.
During 28th January 1965, The Eastern Banking Corporation inaugurated its operation in East Pakistan as commercial bank. After 6 months of its inauguration it has got the status of Schedule Bank. It was the first Bengali Owned Commercial Bank. After liberation the Eastern Banking Corporation was changed by name as Uttara Bank Ltd. During 1972 it was taken under national ownership. At that time it’s paid up capital was 69.13 crore and profit figure was 42lac. During September 1983 it was privatized under privatization act. At that time this deposit was 231.03 crore and profit figure was 5.06 up to 2003 its number of branches stands to 198 and it’s paid up capital was 100 million. 95% of its share holder is public and rest of share holds by Government. There are some different year’s deposits, loan, & advances and net profit has been given below.
|Year||Deposit||Loan & Advances (Tk. In cr.)||Net profit (Tk. In Cr.)|
|December 31, 1972||69.13||60.57||.42|
|December 31, 1983||231.03||226.56||5.06|
|December 31, 2001||2594.25||2333.18||120.00|
The all branches are computerized which has been possible by local (within the organization) computerized analyst. The place, where electricity is not available they are maintaining their activities by generator. And that’s why has got access to enter in the instant Global Economy. For reaching immigrant/non-imrnigranls, sending money to the recipients as welt as to invest this money in lucrative sector UBL has established.
- Non-residence Foreign Currency Deposit (NFCD)
- Foreign Current Account Deposit (FCAD)
- Wage Earners Development Bond (WFBD)
- Home (HRC)
- Wage Earners Investment (WEIC)
Historical Background of Uttara Bank Ltd:
Uttara Bank Ltd. has been a nationalized bank in the name of Uttara Bank under the Bangladesh Bank (Nationalization) order 1972, formally known as Eastern Banking Corporation Limited.
- Uttara Bank ltd. started functioning from 28.01.1965
- Consequent upon the amendment of Bangladesh Bank (Nationalization) order 1972
- Uttara Bank ltd. converted into Uttara Bank ltd. as a public limited company in the year 1983 and obtained business commencement certificate on 21.08.1983.
- Uttara Bank ltd. floated its shares in the year 1984.
- Uttara Bank ltd. has 207 branches all over Bangladesh
- The bank is listed in the Dhaka Stock Exchange Ltd. and also in Chittagong Dhaka Stock Exchange Ltd.
- It publicly quoted company for trading of its shears.
- The registered office of the Bank is located in 47, Bir Uttom Shahid Ashfaq-us-samad Road (90, Motijheel Commercial Area), P.O. Box No. 217 & 818 Dhaka-1000, Bangladesh.
Uttara Bank is one of the largest and oldest private-sector commercial bank in Bangladesh, with years of experience. Adaptation of modern technology both in terms of equipment and banking practice ensures efficient service to clients. 207 branches at home and 600 affiliates worldwide create efficient networking and reach capability. Uttara is a bank that serves both clients and country.
Corporate Governance is the system by which business companies are directed and controlled. Since its inception, Uttara Bank has actively and fully adhered to the principle of sound corporate governance. Fairness, Transparency Accountability and Responsibility are the minimum standard of acceptable corporate behavior today. Uttara Bank Limited continues to ensure the compliance of corporate Governance as per Securities and Exchange Commission rules and regulations. Corporate governance establishes specific responsibility and ensures accountability
Corporate Social Responsibility:
The basic driver of CSR consists of values that have taken place within businesses where they not only feel responsible for creation of wealth but also for social and environmental well being. Uttara Bank Ltd. considers socially responsible activities as an important part of its culture, identity and business practice. We have a deep commitment, loyalty and a high sense of responsibility to our nation and its people. Uttara Bank Ltd. conforms to all of the astringent regulations issued by the Government and the Bangladesh Bank. As per of our corporate social responsibility, Bank contributes greatly to the nourishment of the country’s all types of calamities, arts, culture and sports.
Vision/Mission, Strategies Statement:
The bank has some mission to achieve the organizational goals. Some of them are as follows-
- The bank looks forward with excitement and a commitment to bring greater benefits to customers.
- Uttara Bank Limited provides high quality financial services to strengthen the well-being and success of individual, industries and business communities.
- Its aim to ensure their competitive advantages by upgrading banking technology and information system.
- UBL intends to play more important role in the economic development of Bangladesh and its financial relations with the west of the world by interlinking both modernistic and international operations.
- The bank intends to meet the needs of their clients and enhance their profitability by creating corporate market.
- The Bank has remained dynamic in its continued efforts to improve & increase core competence & service efficiency by constantly upgrading product quality, service standards, protocol and their effective participation making use of state of the art technology.
- The bank creates wealth for the shareholders
- The bank believes in strong capitalization.
- Its maintain high standard of corporate and business ethics.
- UBL extend highest quality of services, which attracts the customers to choose them first.
General Activities of the organization:
General Banking is the starting point of all banking operation. It is a combination of activities of different sections.
General banking has some section in the bank. These sections are as follows:
- Accounts Opening Section.
- Cash Section.
- Clearing Section.
- Remittance Section.
- Accounts Section.
Accounts Opening Section:
Opening account with a bank is the way of creating a banker customer relationship. In other words, it is a contract between banker and customer. With this contract, bankers enter into certain obligations and responsibilities.
Proper introduction serves as a precaution against fraud and forgeries and safeguard against inadvertent overdraft to bank. Obtaining proper introduction may absolve the banker from the charges of negligence for conversion. So, while opening a new account, emphasis would be given without exception to introductory reference and inquiry. The following instruction to be followed while opening account: –
- Introduction of Account to be obtained from a respectable client acceptable to bank.
- The introduction shall be obtained in writing in the respective column of Account opening form.
- For opening savings bank account of individual either singly or jointly, passports and identity cards may be accepted for introduction, but subsequently proper introduction may be obtained.
- Introduction of Current Account by members of the staff may be allowed but shall be discouraged as far as possible.
- Current Account shall preferably be introduced by another Current Account holder acceptable to bank.
Other products and services:
Along side traditional banking product and services, the bank has some tailor made products in liability and asset sides. Of those mentionable are Monthly Savings Scheme and Double Benefit scheme etc. for deposit mobilization in one hand and consumer credit scheme, lease finance, personal loan, Uttara house repairing and renovation Scheme and SME financing in other hand. Besides, the Bank has also some electro-products based on information technology of which Q-cash UBL ATM Debit cards are to be mentioned for providing 24 hours services to customers.
Different Banking Sectors Limited:
Uttara Bank is a major player in Bangladesh wholesale banking industry to offer the full scope of innovative, customized solutions and services. We offer service at the highest level. Our focus is not on short-term profit, but on building long-term relationships and standing by our clients whenever they need us.
Working Capital Finance:
A convenient and flexible form of short-term financing for routine operating expenses and overheads of your company
Guarantees and Bonds:
Uttara Bank issues a full range of Performance Guarantees, Advance Payment Guarantees, and Financial Guarantees and Bid bonds for supporting the underlying business of our customers.
Uttara Bank’s trade finance is tailored to meet the individual needs of your business. We can help even if your company has limited unstructured credit lines, due to reasons such as limited financial resources or sudden spike requirements.
Short & Mid-term Finance:
Short Term Financing:
As the responsive player in market, you may anytime need fund to utilize for a very short time due to either emergency or short term projects. In such case, Uttara Bank is there to facilitate you.
Mid Term Financing:
Uttara Bank can also equip you the required fund for a longer period. If you worry about fund requirement for a bit longer, ‘Uttara Bank Term Loan’ will make you feel confident that, you got a friend for this.
Uttara bank has been very active in the finance in a Project:
Our project financing solutions:
- Mitigate sponsor exposure to project risk.
- Enhance use of leverage to increase project returns by lowering the weighted average cost of capital.
Lease and Long Term Loans:
We can customize a Term Loan or Lease to finance the fixed assets that your business needs (such as land, new premises, equipment and machinery). It may be a Greenfield project or an expansion of an existing plant, which may be financed at competitive floating rate of interest.
With over 1.5 billion Muslims in the world, the global Islamic funds market is currently valued at USD 750 billion and is expected to grow exponentially every year.
Products of Islamic finance
- Bai Muajjal: For financing procurement of raw material where goods are kept under customer’s custody.
- Bai Murabaha: For financing procurement of raw material where goods are kept under bank’s custody.
- Hire Purchase under Shirkatul Melk: For financing procurement of capital machinery.
- Bai Salam: For financing pre-shipment expenses by purchasing exportable goods in advance.
Structured of Finance:
A leading provider of cost-efficient, lease-based and asset-based financing solutions to businesses in Bangladesh, we can create and tailor the right structured solutions for your business needs in order to enhance shareholders’ wealth and your market competitiveness.
These solutions include:
Structured financing solutions: Principal to principal structured capital market transactions optimizes investment returns and reduces effective funding costs.
Syndications: This normally involves getting a group of banks together (forming a syndicate) to provide the loan amount required by the customer under a set of common terms and conditions laid down in a loan agreement.
Cash Management: In today’s competitive financial environment, effective cash management has become a critical success factor. This is the right time to have integrated cash management solution.
Payment Services: We can help you save time and money by reducing processing costs while providing a value-added service to your suppliers.
Collection Services: We have a comprehensive branch network and the local knowledge to help you with lower costs and greater efficiency.
The Uttara Bank Collections Solution leverages the Bank’s extensive regional knowledge and widespread branch network across our key markets to specially tailor solutions for your regional and local collection needs.
Liquidity Management: Let us help you to get the most out of your company’s cash resources with physical sweeping, notional pooling, interest reallocation and investment.
We are a market leader across our footprint in innovative, landmark deals, multi-jurisdiction solutions and sophisticated product structuring for corporate and institutional clients. We hold leading positions in fixed income local currencies and loan syndications. Our in-depth understanding of the local regulatory framework in the domestic debt and loan markets, product expertise and wide geographic reach, help you achieve your financing and investment objectives.
Debt Capital Market:
Our proven knowledge, product capabilities and global reach make us well-suited to matching investors’ needs with the funding requirements of international and domestic issuers.
Asset Backed Securities:
We structure, arrange and distribute asset-backed and future flow transactions for clients and our track record of innovative deals puts us at the forefront of developing securitization markets in our footprint.
We offer investment tools and a range of local currencies to provide structured asset solutions to meet specific investment needs, achieve target yields on your portfolio and manage risk exposure.
Convertible Bonds / Equity Derivatives:
Our convertible bonds and equity derivatives teams open avenues of financing and investing linked to the equity asset class – all underpinned by local market knowledge, deep client relationships and innovation
Balance Inquiries & Statements:
- The account holder may enquire about his/her balance in the account. The client may be advised to fill and sign the Balance Requisition Slip (BRS) or to produce the Letter of Authority (LOA) duly signed by the account holder.
- The signature of the account holder shall be verified on the BRS or LOA before disclosing the balance.
- If a slip is required to be sent by mail or hand, it shall be sent in a closed envelope addressed to the account holder.
In the event of a balance certificate required by an account holder, he/she may be provided with such certificate as per computer print report recorded by the branch against his/her written request. Certificate may be delivered as per instruction of the account holder.
- In a computerized system of accounts, the computer program will provide print report of balance confirmation of Accounts along with a sub-joined part. It will contain the full address of the account holder. The balance confirmation shall be dispatched to account holder in a window envelope. Follow-up should be made to get back the sub-joined part duly signed by the account holder.
- On receipt of the confirmation from the party regarding his/her balance duly signed, it shall be preserved in a file after verification of signature.
- Balance confirmation for debit balances in case of over-draft, cash Credit and/or loan accounts shall be dealt with separately. The sub-joined part to be received from clients duly signed by them and preserved in their document file after verification of signature.
Closing of Accounts:
For different reasons, the account holder(s) may request for closure of his/ their account with the bank. On receipt of such letter of request for closure of account, the Manager should ascertain the reasons to satisfy himself that the constituent is not severing his relations for grievance from the bank which may possibly be redressed. If for genuine reason the account holder(s) approach for closure of his/their account, the following steps shall be taken:
The bank’s deposit stood Tk 50,817.0 million as on December, 2008 compared to Tk 43,586.4 million in 2007, thus recording 16.59 percent growth. Competitive interest rates, attractive deposit products, deposit mobilization efforts of the Bank and confidence reposed by the customers in the Bank contributed to the notable growth in deposit. The Bank evolved a number of attractive Deposit Schemes to cater to the requirement of small and medium savers. These helped to improved not only the quantum of deposits but also to bring about qualitative changes in deposit structure.
out ward clearing:
All cheques, demand drafts and other credit instruments tendered for the credit of customers account will be delivered by the depositor at the clearing counter. Any deposits received by post will also be sent over to the clearing counter. The counter officer shall at the time of receipt examine such deposits carefully to ensure that:
- The name of the account is very clearly written on the Deposit slips.
- The particulars of deposits such as cheque numbers, names of bank etc. are properly entered on the deposit slip.
- The depositor has signed the Deposit Slip.
- Local Office/Main Branch shall receive cheques etc drawn on Uttara Bank Limited branches from the Clearing House. On receipt of the cheque etc. they shall segregate the same branch-wise and issue IBDA on branches against total amount of cheque etc. and shall arrange delivery of the UBL together with the cheques etc. within Clearing House time schedule.
- Branches shall send the cheques dishonored by them supported by UBL issued on Local Office/Main Branch, within Clearing House time schedule for enabling Local Office/ Main Branch to return these instruments in the 2nd Clearing House.
Receipt of Cash:
Cash may be deposited either by deposit Slips for SB/ CD/ CC accounts or by other credit voucher like single credit voucher, pay order/ Draft/ T.T. application forms. Branches shall ensure the following:
- Cash receiving officer shall check the deposit slip/ credit voucher/ application form as to its title of account, number and amount in words and figures.
- The cash currency notes shall be counted physically /by cash counting machine as per denominations of the currency notes on the back of the voucher /deposit slip. The officer will enter the particulars in the cash Receiving Register and sign on the related deposit slip/voucher and affix “Cash Received” Stamp with date.
Payment of Cash:
Cheques, Cash Debit Vouchers, Fixed Deposit Receipts, Monthly Term Deposit Receipts, Bearer Certificates of Deposit, Demand Drafts, may be placed for payment at the counter by clients, beneficiaries and various departments for encashment. Branches shall ensure the following:
- The instrument is checked for any apparent discrepancy and evidence of posting and cancellation.
- Specimen Signature of cancellation officer shall be available with cash paying officer for convenience of payment.
Foreign Exchange Activities
Foreign Exchange Department:
Foreign Exchange department deals with foreign currency and the transaction of it. The major jobs of this department are listed below:
- Letter of Credit
- Dollar/Traveler’s Check Endorsement.
- Foreign Remittance Foreign Currency Account.
The functions of Foreign Exchange Department can be divided into three parts
- Import: Purchasing goods and services from outside Bangladesh and purchase of goods locally under local Back to Back L/C against export is also treated as import.
- Export: Selling of goods and services outside home country in known as EXPORT, but selling of goods within home country under B.B L/C (against Exp L/C) is also treated as Export.
- Remittance: Remittance represents transfer of fund from one place to another through official channel.
Credit Division (Uttara Bank Ltd)
Credit Department is one of the important departments of Uttara Bank Ltd. One of the primary functions of commercial banks is to create the claim against individual borrowers or real sector of the economy through purchasing the primary securities for the purpose of sanctioning credit. Banks grant loan in the form of different securities. By the primary we mean the financial claim of holder against the real sector of the economy. In banking the financial claim of a bank is against issuer i.e. investors, borrowers and deficit units. Bank credit is very important for bringing economic development in a country. Without adequate finance there can be no growth or maintenance of stable economy. Bank lending is important for the economy, for it makes possible the financing of agriculture, commercial and industrial activities of a nation. At the same time, a bank will, therefore, distribute its funds among various sectors in a manner as to derive sufficient incomes.
Principles of Sound Lending:
Uttara Bank Limited follows the following principles of sound lending.
UBL firstly considers the safety of the bank’s money. In case of lending, the bank invests depositor’s money, So, depositors’ interest as well as bank’s interest must be protected by making investment is such a way that can be safely returned both profit/interest and principal.
UBL does not sanction any loan without taking appropriate security. Generally this branch gives loan taking two types of security. Such as
- Primary Security such as FDR, DPS, DDS, SDS, Merchandise Goods, etc.
- Secondary or Collateral Security such as Land & Building.
UBL provides loans and advances to selected borrowers taking into consideration the liquidity position of the borrower i.e. nature of business, security etc and also the liquidity position of the bank. This bank maintains the liquidity requirements of Bangladesh Bank and its customers.
The main objective of UBL as a private commercial bank is to earn profit and it is a business organization. So the bank gives loans and advances in profitable sectors not in charitable organizations.
UBL raises funds from the public at lower costs and invests the funds to the borrowers at a higher interest rate. The difference is the spread/margin/profit of the bank. UBL considers profitability before making investment in a project.
Another important point of sound lending is to consider great national interest. This bank does not finance any project, which is engaged in anti-national activity.
|Superior – Low Risk||1||Facilities are fully secured by cash deposits, government bonds or a counter guarantee from a top tier international bank. All security documentation should be in place.|
|Good – Satisfactory Risk||2||The repayment capacity of the borrower is strong. The borrower should have excellent liquidity and low leverage. The company should demonstrate consistently strong earnings and cash flow and have an unblemished track record. All security documentation should be in place. Aggregate Score of 95 or greater based on the Risk Grade Scorecard.|
|Acceptable – Fair Risk||3||Adequate financial condition though may not be able to sustain any major or continued setbacks. These borrowers are not as strong as Grade 2 borrowers, but should still demonstrate consistent earnings, cash flow and have a good track record. A borrower should not be graded better than 3 if realistic audited financial statements are not received. These assets would normally be secured by acceptable collateral (1st charge over stocks / debtors / equipment / property). Borrowers should have adequate liquidity, cash flow and earnings. An Aggregate Score of 75-94 based on the Risk Grade Scorecard.|
|Marginal – Watch list||4||Grade 4 assets warrant greater attention due to conditions affecting the borrower, the industry or the economic environment. These borrowers have an above average risk due to strained liquidity, higher than normal leverage, thin cash flow and/or inconsistent earnings. Facilities should be downgraded to 4 if the borrower incurs a loss, loan payments routinely fall past due, account conduct is poor, or other untoward factors are present. An Aggregate Score of 65-74 based on the Risk Grade Scorecard.|
|Special Mention||5||Grade 5 assets have potential weaknesses that deserve management’s close attention. If left uncorrected, these weaknesses may result in a deterioration of the repayment prospects of the borrower. Facilities should be downgraded to 5 if sustained deterioration in financial condition is noted (consecutive losses, negative net worth, excessive leverage), if loan payments remain past due for 30-60 days, or if a significant petition or claim is lodged against the borrower. Full repayment of facilities is still expected and interest can still be taken into profits. An Aggregate Score of 55-64 based on the Risk Grade Scorecard.|
|Substandard||6||Financial condition is weak and capacity or inclination to repay is in doubt. These weaknesses jeopardize the full settlement of loans. Loans should be downgraded to 6 if loan payments remain past due for 60-90 days, if the customer intends to create a lender group for debt restructuring purposes, the operation has ceased trading or any indication suggesting the winding up or closure of the borrower is discovered. Not yet considered non-performing as the correction of the deficiencies may result in an improved condition, and interest can still be taken into profits. An Aggregate Score of 45-54 based on the Risk Grade Scorecard.|
|Doubtful and Bad|
|7||Full repayment of principal and interest is unlikely and the possibility of loss is extremely high. However, due to specifically identifiable pending factors, such as litigation, liquidation procedures or capital injection, the asset is not yet classified as Loss. Assets should be downgraded to 7 if loan payments remain past due in excess of 90 days, and interest income should be taken into suspense (non-accrual). Loan loss provisions must be raised against the estimated unrealisable amount of all facilities. The adequacy of provisions must be reviewed at least quarterly on all non-performing loans, and the bank should pursue legal options to enforce security to obtain repayment or negotiate an appropriate loan rescheduling. In all cases, the requirements of Bangladesh Bank in CIB reporting, loan rescheduling and provisioning must be followed. An Aggregate Score of 35-44 based on the Risk Grade Scorecard|
|8||Assets graded 8 are long outstanding with no progress in obtaining repayment (in excess of 180 days past due) or in the late stages of wind up/liquidation. The prospect of recovery is poor and legal options have been pursued. The proceeds expected from the liquidation or realization of security may be awaited. The continuance of the loan as a bankable asset is not warranted, and the anticipated loss should have been provided for. This classification reflects that it is not practical or desirable to defer writing off this basically worthless asset even though partial recovery may be effected in the future. Bangladesh Bank guidelines for timely write off of bad loans must be adhered to. An Aggregate Score of 35 or less based on the Risk Grade Scorecard|
At least top twenty five clients/obligors of the Bank may preferably be rated by an outside credit rating agency.
The Early Alert Report (Appendix 3.3.1) should be completed in a timely manner by the RM and forwarded to CRM for approval to affect any downgrade. After approval, the report should be forwarded to Credit Administration, who is responsible to ensure the correct facility/borrower Risk Grades are updated on the system. The downgrading of an account should be done immediately when adverse information is noted, and should not be postponed until the annual review process
The authority to sanction/approve loans must be clearly delegated to senior credit executives by the Managing Director/CEO & Board based on the executive’s knowledge and experience. Approval authority should be delegated to individual executives and not to committees to ensure accountability in the approval process. The following guidelines should apply in the approval/sanctioning of loans:
- Credit approval authority must be delegated in writing from the MD/CEO & Board (as appropriate), acknowledged by recipients, and records of all delegation retained in CRM.
- Delegated approval authorities must be reviewed annually by MD/CEO/Board.
- The credit approval function should be separate from the marketing/relationship management (RM) function.
- The role of Credit Committee may be restricted to only review of proposals i.e. recommendations or review of bank’s loan portfolios.
- Approvals must be evidenced in writing, or by electronic signature. Approval records must be kept on file with the Credit Applications.
- All credit risks must be authorized by executives within the authority limit delegated to them by the MD/CEO. The “pooling” or combining of authority limits should not be permitted.
- Credit approval should be centralized within the CRM function. Regional credit centers may be established, however, all large loans must be approved by the Head of Credit and Risk Management or Managing Director/CEO/Board or delegated Head Office credit executive.
- The aggregate exposure to any borrower or borrowing group must be used to determine the approval authority required.
- Any credit proposal that does not comply with Lending Guidelines, regardless of amount, should be referred to Head Office for Approval
- MD/Head of Credit Risk Management must approve and monitor any cross-border exposure risk.
- Any breaches of lending authority should be reported to MD/CEO, Head of Internal Control, and Head of CRM.
Segregation of Duties
Banks should aim to segregate the following lending functions:
- Credit Approval/Risk Management
- Relationship Management/Marketing
- Credit Administration
The purpose of the segregation is to improve the knowledge levels and expertise in each department, to impose controls over the disbursement of authorised loan facilities and obtain an objective and independent judgment of credit proposals.
Banks should have a segregated internal audit/control department charged with conducting audits of all departments. Audits should be carried out annually, and should ensure compliance with regulatory guidelines, internal procedures, and Lending Guidelines and Bangladesh Bank requirements.
Revised Credit Proposal:
The following Information should be included in the Credit Proposals/ Memos along with the existing format:
- Customer ID Number
- Tax Identification Number
- Approval Authority
- Capital Structure Key Financial Indicators Client’s Risk Grade Single borrower/group limit of the Bank.
A thorough credit and risk assessment should be conducted prior to granting of loans, and at least annually thereafter for all facilities. Thus appraising a credit is the most challenging job for credit personnel. His / her intension is to define and minimize potential risks associated with a credit so as to secure return of money together with the appropriate charges for use of the money. Although nobody can cent percent guarantee the future of a credit as because business may be subject to the effects beyond the control of either of banker or of borrower, experience shows that in properly apprised credits banker is likely to lose only a tiny proportion of what he lends.
Credit Applications should summarize the results of the risk assessment and include, as a minimum, the following details:
Credit policy of UBL
The credit apprising personnel should be through about the prevailing credit policy of UBL in force. The officials should go by the sprit of the credit policy set by the bank through ‘Credit Risk Management Policy’, Head Office letters & circulars as well as through the deliberations of top management of the bank from time to time.
Diversification of portfolio
Branches shall exercise vigilance to avoid concentration of portfolio in a particular sector of the economy or nature of business viz. import, export, trading etc. However, some branches are located in areas that are earmarked for a particular activity and in such an area optimal diversification may not be possible. If so care shall be taken to diversify within the particular line of business in respect of nature of operation such as producer, importer, wholesaler, retailer etc.
Branches shall also be careful to avoid excessive concentration of advances in the hands of few clients.
Familiarity with the borrower
Credit personnel should have a through knowledge about the past and present of the borrower. If the borrower is a non-human legal entity, the familiarity should be with the past and present of the controlling persons. Usually there are one or two key persons in an organization irrespective of their position as Chief Executive Officer of the company and proper care shall be exercised in gathering and dissemination of information about such persons.
A basic consideration in extending credit is the integrity of the borrower. Integrity of the borrower can be termed as necessary factor for the selection of borrower. Unless branch is fully satisfied about the integrity of the client, no credit facility shall be extended.
Consideration of human element in borrower’s notion towards repayment of bank debt as well as past track record with the bank may throw an insight into the integrity of the existing client. For a new client utmost care shall be taken to assess integrity of the borrowers usually through face to face interview, track record with other banks /financial institutions, if any, establishing his background and ability.
Competence of the borrower has to be properly analyzed. Competence of a client may be reflected in his ability to furnish the required information as well as in attending the requested assistance.
Besides the bank must know the borrower / management well enough, that the borrower / management fully understands the problems its business / company faces, and that it is taking the appropriate actions to improve and / or restore its credit worthiness.
The bank must know exactly what for the money will be utilized. It shall be ascertained at the outset that the intended purpose is a legal one as per existing government policy. Besides, it shall also be ascertained that the selected sector of activity is expected to be sufficiently remunerative to bear the cost of bank finance as well as provides adequate return to cover borrower’s expected margin as well. Branches should not entertain financing in a purely speculative purpose.
Borrower’s track record in respect of credit history shall be obtained. This will again consist of both formal and informal sources. Information through informal sources particularly helps to ascertain the credit utilization pattern of the borrower.
Formal sources such as obtaining status report through CIB and bank checking depicts client’s present credit position. In a relevant case, care shall be taken to work out borrower’s present level of aggregate credit arrangement with all the financing institutions.
Optimum level of credit worthiness
Borrower’s optimum level of credit worthiness is very crucial factor in making a decision on a lending proposal. Especially in case of big borrowers this factor shall be carefully evaluated and all the credit facilities extended to the client by all financing institutions shall be taken into account. The branch shall entertain no proposal exceeding the optimum level of credit worthiness of the borrower at a particular point of time.
Extent of facility
The extent of facility requested shall be evaluated properly. The purpose, business type as well as optimum level of operation in respect of sectoral absorption capacity, management capability of business etc. are to be considered to determine an optimum extent of the facility.
For appraising a credit, borrowers’ stake shall be ascertained in real terms. The nature of stake such as cash, fixed asset (in case of project finance) etc. shall also be taken into consideration.
Source and terms of repayment
The repayment proposal of the client shall be very clear in respect of source of repayment as well as terms of repayment. Usually it shall be ensured that the proposed lending is a self liquidating one i.e. the finance in its own accord generate sufficient funds to repay the borrowing within a reasonable period of time. If the lending is not self liquidating, alternative sources shall be carefully checked in respect of its suitability. Generally third party source shall be avoided.
Repayment period is another aspect to be looked carefully. In evaluating this aspect following two factors, among others, shall be considered:
- that the bank essentially deal in short term fund and as such if the repayment period extends beyond one year the same shall be evaluated, inter alia, in terms of branch’s vis-à-vis bank’s already undertaken stakes in financing with such repayment schedule and
- That branch should be aware in respect of changing economic and political effects on such lending, particularly covering the repayment period.
Every credit carries certain risks and as such risk factors in respect of business as well as security shall be properly analyzed and defined. Wherever relevant mathematical tools shall be applied.
Balance sheet analysis
For corporate clients, analysis of balance sheet is a must. Among the various techniques of analyzing balance sheet credit officials shall at least concentrate on some of the commonly used techniques.
Other considerations being good, profitability of the proposal shall be the prime concern of the apprising officer as because the essential purpose of lending is to maximize profit.
Working out of spread and net spread are of very importance so as to provide the bank shareholders’ with an adequate return on their capital as well as to grow the business.
Spread is the difference between proposed rate of interest on lending and average cost of fund. In case of net spread, with the cost of fund overhead of the branch is added to ascertain branch’s net profit from the deal.
Due to wide spread prevalence of default culture and conversely absence of a healthy practice in repayment of debt, we usually insist on tangible collateral securities.
The basic consideration in evaluation of security would be : the easiest to realize, the best. As such best security is cash collateral followed by legal charges over property and other tangible assets. However regarding security the points to consider are type, value, ownership and reliability.
Appraisal of risks
Although measuring exact extent of credit risk is rarely possible, proper investigation and careful analysis help a credit appraiser in indicating whether the risk is small or great to undertake. In apprising credit the following risk needs to be analyzed.
In ascertaining business risk the credit appraiser’s purpose is to identify the nature and extent of risk in respect of likelihood of the business that the same fails to generate sufficient return to repay the loan as per arrangement. If any business carries a substantial risk that it will fail to generate adequate return, the same shall not be entertained for financing. The aim of financing is to go with the business which is a fairly good performer in the particular area of trade / industry. For trading concerns, firm’s / company’s location, past performance, turnover as well as its position in its line of operation / command over the market etc. shall be considered. For concerns producing intermediary / finished products, it’s financial positions for last few years (usually statement of immediate past 3 years) need to be analyzed so as to track it’s performance / trend in performing as well as level of cash flow so as to reflect the repaying capacity of the same. Besides quality of products and their competitive edge over the identical products of other concerns shall have to be taken into consideration.
Resourcefulness of a firm / company takes account of liquidity position of its business as well as that of its owner’s or major shareholders’, as the case may be, level of liability in respect of equity, its ability to reduce costs (if need be) as well as effective connections on the part of the owners / management with the relevant segment of the society so as to benefit in case of adverse situation. Highly resourceful business shows its ability to withstand any adverse change in business as well as economic conditions under which it operates and such companies are usually welcome for financing.
Through management risk, appraiser’s purpose is to evaluate management’s competence and it’s integrity. It identifies the persons who are actually calling the shots and their integrity as well as ability to guide / make decisions to carry the business.
Management integrity and competence is one of the necessary aspects for the success of a business. Again management integrity fills the necessary condition and competence of them acts as sufficient conditions in assessing management risk.
As already said, unlike developed economies, for different reasons a greater part of our lending is usually secured by collateral security. However, for primary security to be at bank’s control (such as goods/properties under pledge, LIM etc.), the security risk is also to be assessed.
Assessing risks associated with the reliability of the security is of particular importance to the appraiser so as to, apart from the moral pressure on the borrower; ascertain the degree of cushion to fall back upon in case of need. To evaluate security risk, its location, quality, controllability, ready and future value as well as marketability, process and estimated cost in disposing off the property etc. shall be analyzed. Besides the extent of open portion of finance, if any, in respect of forced sale value of the security shall have to be ascertained.
Risks of advance & decision on advance:
Combining business and security risks, the appraiser gets the nature and extent of risks associated with a particular advance upon which accepting a credit depends.
It shall be borne in mind that there is very few credit requests that have no risk. Therefore, appraiser shall have a constructive approach and not be inclined to only undertake perfect risks. But there are some risks that carry a small possibility of loss and there are other risks that are too great to assume.
The appraiser should approach each economically sound credit request with a desire to find some safe and proper way to complete the transaction so that the customer may be served and the bank is benefited thereby. However, when the purpose of advance is unsound or when risk appears too great to undertake the proposal shall be declined steadfastly. The credit relationship is founded on trust and UBL must be entirely satisfied with the integrity of all parties in any relationship.
Credits shall be evaluated rationally by UBL, with the benefit of a thorough understanding of the borrower’s business affairs and the attendant risks. The Branch Manager must have a detailed knowledge of each specific credit transaction and of any particular risks associated with the transaction as distinct from the activities of the borrower.
All credit transactions should be justifiable by analysis of the attendant risks and sources of repayment / redemption without allowing for considerations of security. Credit relationships based on security considerations alone are against this credit policy.
With the mass production and distribution conditions business the operations are changing fast. Today the businesses are not necessarily a small entity, owned and operated by one individual.
Besides it is becoming increasingly difficult on the part of a banker to have detailed knowledge of the integrity, ability, financial performance etc. of the borrower in appraising a credit. As such appraisers today are more dependent on the analyses of different financial statements of which balance sheet and profit & loss statement are of great importance.
However due to various reasons it shall be kept in mind that analyses of financial statements and statement proportions can not be relied upon conclusively for extension of bank credit. Rather those provide a helping hand to arrive at a decision to accept or reject the credit.
Audited and Unaudited statements
Financial statements may be audited or un audited. However branches shall always prefer to work on audited statement as there is always a strong possibility that owners may lean toward the optimistic side in preparing its (un audited) financial statement for credit purposes. As such an independent, outside verification of account values is needed to obtain an objective viewpoint.
Reliability of statements
At the outset the appraiser shall form an idea about the reliability of the statement. Only acceptable statements be analyzed and unfortunately there is no infallible means to employ to label a statement as reliable or not. However a workable judgment can be formed by taking into account the factors like the style /integrity of management of the business as well as market standing in respect of accountants, who have audited the statements, relating to their expertise and professional integrity.
Window dressing is a very commonly known terminology to all the appraisers. There are many ways in which financial statements may be dressed up to make an improved showing within the bounds of legal technicalities because of the fact that the statements are prepared as at the close of one day and the knowledge that it is to be used as a basis for requesting credit. However the difficulty is that in this case also there is no infallible means to employ, rather the appraiser has to apply his commonsense relying on his experience and judgment in detecting manipulations. He must question suspiciously strong statements and proportions.
Purpose of analyzing statements
Before analyzing financial statements two questions shall be answered first:
- Where he (analyst) wants to go and
- Why he is analyzing.
Besides while analyzing followings, among others, shall always be kept in mind:
- the amount of loan requested
- the purpose(s) for which loan will be used
- The proposed repayment period of the loan and
- The source(s) for repayment of loan.
UTTARA BANK SME PROGRAM
SME CREDIT PROGRAM
Uttara Bank Limited has come forward to extend its services towards Micro and Small & Medium Enterprises sector with a new product group, the all new SME (Small & Medium Enterprise) credit program.
Uttara Bank ha a firm commitment to contribute to every segment of Bangladesh. This is one of the steps toward the fulfillment of this commitment.
- Contribute to the socio-economic development of Bangladesh.
- To promote the underserved, who can’t go a long way due to lack of financial support.
- Create employment opportunity.
- Increase contribution of SME sector to GDP.
WHAT IS SME
The definition of Small and Middle Enterprises (SME) varies according to context. The way SME is defined in the UK or the US is hardly the way to define it in the context of the developing countries. However, there are some general criteria on the basis of which SMEs are defined in both the developed and developing countries. These criteria are-
- Number of employees in the firm.
- Assets employed.
- Sales turnover
- Employee turnover
- Asset and turnover ratio
Since a universally accepted definition of SMEs is yet to appear, it is better to conceptualize them through their characteristics. The these characteristics again can be viewed from two contexts-
The characteristics that SMEs generally exhibit are as follow-
- These are managed in a personalized way by their owners or partners.
- SMEs have small share of market and usually do not have access to the stock market for raising capital.
- SMEs have limited access to formal channels of finance and depend on the savings of owner(s), family and friends.
- Most SMEs are sole proprietorship and partnership.
- Most of the SMEs in APEC countries consist of less than 100 employees. However, variations may be found in this figure in case of some countries; for example, China employs less than 500 people in a SME, Korea, Japan employ less than 300, Thailand, Vietnam and Philippine employ less than 200 and Malaysia employs less than 150 people.
The asset base of SMEs is also an important characteristic but it is more particular rather than a general characteristic. The small-scale enterprises in Srilanka have assets equivalent to Rs.1 to 20 million while in India these enterprises possess assets of Rs.1 to 10 million. So, we will find varying pictures in different countries with regard to the asset base of SMEs
Particular characteristics in Bangladesh context:
In the context of Bangladesh, most SMEs exhibit the following, if not all characteristics-
- They are sector and location neutral.
- They employ a mix of family and hired workers.
- They usually use no division of labour.
- They hardly follow any modern and/or accounting system.
- They usually exhibit low to medium level work skill.
- They are usually local raw material based.
- They usually apply personal marketing endeavors.
This paper focuses on the SMEs in Bangladesh. Therefore it is important to define these enterprises in the context of this country. The “East Pakistan Small Industry Act XVII” of 1957 for the first time provided a definition of SME and still today this is the only official definition existing in Bangladesh. The Act says-
“Small industry means an industrial establishment or unit which is run mainly by hired labour and not using mechanical motive power but does not employ more than 50 workmen and whose land, building and machinery do not exceed tk 250,000 in value either case.”
The definition is quite old and hardly fits in today’s context. Nowadays, firms employing more than 50 employees and using machine power are also classified as SMEs. So, we see that the definition of SME is ever changing and based on situational parameters. In the New Industrial Policy of 2003 Enterprises employing less than 50 workers have been identified as SMEs. The following table summarizes the industry classification by the government of Bangladesh.
Table 1: Industry Classification
|Type of industry||Investment (tk)|
|Medium industry||Tk 250 to Tk 500 million|
|Small industry||Tk 100 to Tk 250 million|
Source: Bangladesh Enterprise Institute (BEI
An overview of Existing SME Credit Program
Although the effort started with the help of some donor agencies since 2001 Uttara Bank Limited has been actively involved with financing SMEs since early 2003. The SME Credit Program for Uttara Bank Limited has been designed in the light of the terms & conditions by USAID, as it was the first advising agent for SME Credit Program. A brief description of UBL SME Credit Program has been given below before going to the Five Years Plan for SME Credit Program:
Product Feature under SME:
As Uttara Bank Limited has launched products under the umbrella of Loan Portfolio Guarantee of USAID, the products has been designed for Micro Enterprise & Small Business rather than Medium Enterprises. It is mentionable that in future we will go for further new products depending on the response & success of the products launched recently.
The products for Micro Enterprise & Small Business are as follows:
i) Micro Enterprise Promotional Credit (MPC)
ii) Small Business Promotional Credit (SPC)
Purpose of Loan: Loans may be given to any of the following purposes:
i) Working Capital
ii) Fixed Asset
Nature of Facility:
i) Overdraft (OD) – In case of Working Capital financing
ii) Term Loan – In case of Fixed Asset financing
Dealer Finance – Under this program Uttara Bank Limited facilitates the dealer of the Large Corporate unit by financing them for procurement of goods.
Receivable Finance – Under this program the bank facilitates the suppliers of the large corporate against the purchase order/ work order.
No-Funded facilitates – The bank now a dys provide and approve various no funded facilities like LC and Bank Guarantee in order to fill the vertical gap in need of the customer. The bank allows to open LC and then retire it by creating LTR which is a funded facility in order to import various machinery for the company itself or raw material or other spares to supply them to the large corporate against supply order.
On the other hand it provides Bank guarantee in order to facilitate the customer to submit bid-bon or performance-bond against the work order.
Interest & charges will apply for both MPC & SPC as follows:
Interest Rate : 15.00% p.a.
Utilization Fee : 1.50% p.a.
Supervision fee : 1% p.a. to be realized upfront.
Loan Processing Fee: In addition to the above, a Loan Processing Fee of 0.50% will be charged once on the total amount before disbursement of the loan.
Facility Period & Repayment:
|Nature of Facility||Period||Moratorium/|
|Overdraft||One year||Nil||within one year|
|Term Loan||Three years||Three (3) months|
|33 equal monthly installments|
commencing from the 4th month
Nature of Borrower:
Borrowers of the following natures will be eligible for SME credit:
i) Proprietorship concern
ii) Partnership concern
iii) Limited Company
iv) Group of enterprises
Nature of Business:
Enterprises of each of the following natures will be eligible for availing SME credit:
i) Manufacturing Enterprises
ii) Trading Enterprises
iii) General Service Rendering Enterprises
iv) Professional Service Rendering Units i.e. medical, engineering, agricultural, architectural etc. services units. In this case, loans may be considered in the name of individuals e. doctors, engineers, agriculturists, architects etc.
Area of Business:
Enterprises doing business in the following area will be entitled for the UBL MPC & SPC:
- Small & Cottage industry
- Agro-processing industry
- Information Technology and Software Development
- Garments Industry
- Light Engineering
- Any Export oriented business
- Any Import substitute business
- Capital Machinery/equipment for professional services i.e. Medical, Engineering, Architectural, Agricultural services etc.
- Garments backward linkage industry
- Printing industry
- Packaging industry
- Decoration products industry
- Food & Beverage industry
- Laundry, Tele-network, Power etc. services
SEDF has chosen 4 industries as priority industries. These are:
i) Agro-processing industry
ii) Information Technology & Software Development,
iii) Garments Industry and
iv) Light Engineering
- Branch Manager
- Branch Credit In-charge
- Branch Credit officers
- SME Unit of Head Office
Client Selection Authority
- Branch Manager
- SME Unit of Head Office
- Urban Area
- Semi-Urban Area
- Rural Area
Semi-urban and rural area are the most focus point for the SME fiancé of Uttara Bank Limited.
Clients Selection Process:
The Credit managers of the branches will be responsible for appraising, scrutinizing & processing of loan applications under SME credit program. Micro Enterprise & Small Business generally do not maintain any proper financials. So, it is difficult to justify creditworthiness and appraise & select clients for Micro & Small Credits. In this regard, the borrowers to be selected in a very careful manner applying branch/credit manager’s own prudence & subjective judgment. Some points are mentioned bellow to help the managers in selecting clients for SME products:
i) The borrower must be well known to the bank
ii) The owner(s) of the enterprise must be energetic and innovative;
iii) The owner(s) must have entrepreneurship quality;
iv) The owner(s) must have good command over the business & be well conversant in technical know how;
vi) The owner(s) must be of integrity;
vii) The owner(s) must be competent in management;
According to USAID, each loan must be a “Qualifying Loan” to be considered under Loan Portfolio Guarantee. A loan will be considered as “Qualifying Loan” which is a new or net additional Local Currency credit including commercial loan, overdraft, letter of credit, guarantee to qualifying micro or small enterprise for any productive or commercial activity qualifying the following criteria:
i) If the borrower is an individual, the borrower must be a national or permanent resident of the country;
ii) If the borrower is a business entity, it must be majority-owned by nationals or permanent residents of the country and/or business entities that are owned by such nationals or residents;
iii) The borrower must be 100% privately owned, controlled and operated;
iv) The borrower’s principal place of business must be in the country;
v) The borrower must be a “micro enterprise” for that portion of the Guarantee Portfolio allocated to loans to micro
- If the Borrower is an existing customer of the Bank, the Loan must be additional to the credit already being provided by the Bank and must not be a renewal or extension of a pre-existing Loan.
- The Loan must be made at the market rate of interest and no portion of the Loan may be financed directly or indirectly with subsidized funds.
- At least 50% of the commercial risk of the Loan must be retained by the Bank at all time and no portion of the Loan may be guaranteed by a Governmental Authority or a donor organization (other than USAID).
- The Loan must be placed under Guarantee coverage within 10 business days after the Loan has bee disbursement (for term loans) or approved (for lines of credit and all other credit facilities).
- No Loan once removed from Guarantee coverage may thereafter be placed again under Guarantee coverage without written consent of USAID.
Business Environment and Private Sector Development
Despite higher economic growth during the 1990s, Bangladesh still lagged behind other countries in the region such as India, Pakistan, and Sri Lanka. Various studies carried out under Asian Development Bank (ADB) TA in 20027 and 2003,8 an investment climate assessment by the WB,9 the 2003 National Private Sector Survey of Enterprises in Bangladesh (the 2003 Private Sector Survey),10 and surveys by the Federation of Bangladesh Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FBCCI) have identified major impediments to the country’s competitiveness and economic growth, including inadequacies in infrastructure facilities (particularly power, gas, and port facilities), corruption and “invisible” costs, deficiencies in the legal and regulatory framework, and lack of access to finance by businesses.
Nevertheless, the Government has taken several policy initiatives to improve the investment climate. The I-PRSP recognizes the private sector as the engine of economic
growth. The 1999 Industrial Policy eliminated restrictions on private sector participation in all sectors except defense, nuclear energy, forest plantation, and mechanized extraction of reserved forests. The foreign direct investment regime is also liberal, although the bulk of direct investment from abroad has been in the gas and power subsectors. With regard to trade reform, the Government has introduced a three-tier tariff structure with the maximum rate having been reduced from 30% to 25%. The average tariff and the number of products subject to quantitative restrictions have also been reduced. Import-licensing requirements have been streamlined. The Government has introduced export promotion measures and at the same time developed a comprehensive plan to cope with the phaseout of the Multi-Fibre Arrangement (MFA) at end- 2004, which will adversely affect textiles and garments, the strategic exports of Bangladesh.
Reforms are also under way to create an enabling environment for private sector development and development partners, including ADB, are providing continuing support for infrastructure development. To tackle the issue of corruption and rent-seeking behavior of public officials, the Government set up the Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) under the ACC Act passed in February 2004. The WB’s Development Support Credit I and II projects as well as the ADB’s ongoing TA provide support for the establishment of the ACC. In addition, the Government is promoting e-governance and introducing the use of computers and web sites in all ministries and sector corporations to enhance transparency and expedite administrative processes.
Government and Central Banks encourage SME finance to facilitate some socio-economic benefits as follows –
In developing economy SME form a significant part in the national economy. It is generally recognized that SMEs have a significant role in generating growth and employment. SMEs account for about 40% of gross manufacturing output, about 80% of
industrial employment, and about 25% of the total labor force in Bangladesh. Preliminary figures based on the 2001–2003 Census of Non-Farm Economic Activities (Urban and Rural) [the Economic Census], which excludes agriculture, fisheries, and forestry, estimate the number of persons employed by SMEs at 1.72 million, which is about 45% of the total number employed in nonfarm small, medium, and large establishments.
The 2003 Private Sector Survey estimated that micro, small, and medium enterprises contributed around 20–25% of GDP. Given the critical role of SMEs in economic growth and poverty reduction, it is imperative that the Government develop and implement targeted policy measures to address specific constraints to SMEs to enable them to realize their full potential and contribute more effectively to economic growth and employment generation.
In the year 2005 the GDP growth in our country was registered at 6.9 per cent. The largest growth came from industrial sector which is 8.5 per cent. The large-medium and small scale industry grew by 8.7 per cent and 7.9 percent respectively.
There are varying estimates of the SME population in line with different definitions of SMEs. Based on the Economic Census, the total number of SMEs13 is estimated at 79,754 establishments, of which 93.6% are small and 6.4% are medium. The 2003 Private Sector Survey estimated about 6 million micro, small, and medium enterprises defined as enterprises with fewer than 100 employees.
Development of SME also results in the following –
- Attainment of self-employment and satisfaction; stimulates entrepreneurship.
- Reduces regional imbalances, as all regions are not equally endowed with resources for large industries.
- Plays effective role in reducing the economic backwardness and help improves infrastructures.
- Reduces disparities in income and wealth distribution.
UNDERSTANDING SMALL AND MEDIUM ENTERPRISES
TYPICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF SMEs
- One-man management (lack of balanced managerial skills)
- Multi-tasked employees
- Verbal instructions widely relied upon
- Quick response to identified opportunities
- Close contact with workers, suppliers, customer
- Fast decision making and implementation
- Co-mingling of personal and business funds
- Minimal recording and records-keeping
- Key functions held by family members
- Low capital base (Often inadequate capital)
- Major funds sources are relatives, friends, informal sources
- Flexible production process
- Low level of technology
- Limited product lines (and limited marketing know-how)
COMMON PITFALLS OF SMEs
Some of the common pitfalls of SMEs in respect of – i. Management ii. Market iii. Technical iv. Financial and v. Others – are portrayed as follows –
COMMON PITFALLS OF SMEs – MANAGEMENT ASPECTS –
- Project cost overruns
- Change in project concept
- Absence of full-time manager
- Presence of dishonest manager
- Overexpansion / overdiversification
- Diversion / Misuse of Resources
COMMON PITFALLS OF SMEs – MARKET ASPECTS –
- Dependence on a single market
- Lack of familiarity with the market
- Entry of competition
- Adverse changes in market conditions
COMMON PITFALLS OF SMEs – TECHNICAL ASPECTS –
- Inadequate project planning
- Erroneous choice of project location
- Raw materials shortage/overstocking
- Unreliable power/water supply
- Ineffective quality control
COMMON PITFALLS OF SMEs – FINANCIAL ASPECTS –
- Working capital shortage
- Mismanagement of receivables
- Improper debt management
- Inadequate accounting system
- Ineffective cash management
COMMON PITFALLS OF SMEs – OTHERS –
- Absence of accurate and reliable financial records
- Dependence on future earnings for working capital
- Mismanagement of receivables and payables
- Failure to exert diligence in assessing the paying habits and capability of buyers
- Failure to properly match sales collections with payables
- Failure to monitor maturing obligations
- Failure to understand certain loan covenants
- Failure to segregate business from personal funds
- Involvement of business in family problems
Too much capital in fixed assets
One advantage of the small firm is its low overhead. But if it invests too much of its capital on fixed assets — land, building, machinery — the small firm loses this advantage. Moreover, the working capital available is lessened impairing your flexibility to overcome a crisis or take advantage of an opportunity.
You can avoid investing too much capital in fixed assets by:
- Leasing instead of buying land, building, machinery and equipment.
- Buying on installment
- Purchasing second-hand machinery and equipment if operations and the marketability of your product are not seriously affected.
- Using labor instead of machinery for some operations.
- Subcontracting part or all of the production requirements so that you will not need additional machinery and equipment.
- Acquiring fixed assets that are adequate to meet the requirements of the business, e.g. do not buy a 1000 sq. m. lot if a 500 sq. m. lot will do; do not purchase machinery and equipment that can produce 10,000 units a year if your expected sales is only 5,000 units a year; and
- Make, instead of buying, equipment, furniture and fixtures.
Poor Credit Practices
In your desire to generate more sales, you may be liberal in granting credit. In turn, some of your customers, taking you for granted, delay payment and you find yourself having a hard time paying your own obligations to your employees, suppliers and creditors.
- It is easier said than done but the solution is proper credit control. You should prefer cash paying customers and be more selective in granting credit. Business is business and you should collect even from friends and relatives. Monitor closely your customers whose accounts are due and promptly follow up these accounts. In granting credit, the rule of thumb is to have additional capital equal to 45 days credit sales if you are giving customers 30 days to pay.
- Before granting credit, you must have a positive answer to these two questions: Do I have enough capital? Can I collect?
Poor Cash Management
Related to the previous two issues is poor cash management. Any accountant will tell you that your business may show profit on paper but may have little cash to sustain its operations. You may have attained your sales targets but if most of the sales are on credit, you do not have additional capital and payments are delayed, then you have a cash crisis. Sales may be picking up but you lack cash to purchase additional inventory. You look for additional credit, but, as many businessmen have found out, when you do not need credit, credit is available; when you desperately need credit, no one is willing to lend to you. The mark of a good manager is his ability to prevent a problem from becoming a crisis and this requires planning and foresight.
- The technique to use here is cash flow analysis with which you project your cash flow for the coming months — where the cash will come from, where the cash will be used, how much will be the cash balance, how much additional cash will be needed.
- If you anticipate a need to conserve cash you may decide to keep inventories to a minimum,. seek suppliers who can provide credit, reduce credit sales, seek cash paying customers, get purchases discount or limit investments in fixed assets (see pitfall No. 4).
- Your cash flow projections will become more accurate as you compare projected and actual cash flow and study the differences. A knowledgeable accountant can prepare a cash flow form suitable to your needs.
Limited Marketing Know-how
Your success as a small businessman will ultimately depend on your ability to market your product or service at a profit. Marketing is so basic that it is practically the business itself. Many small business management problems are related to marketing: wrong price, wrong location, poor quality products, inappropriate products, and so forth.
To operate a more competitive and successful business, your way of thinking about marketing should have these characteristics:
- Customer orientation. Although you may be managing your own business, you still have a boss, and that is your customer. Your success as a small business manager depends greatly on how well you can satisfy your customers’ needs. In effect, you are not really selling a product or service but satisfaction of a need. Focus your attention on what your customers need, not on what you can make or provide.
- Integrated activity. Marketing is not an isolated function. Any activity or decision regarding marketing is influenced by or has an effect on other areas and functions within and outside the enterprise. For instance, a plan to develop other products would greatly depend on the firm’s financial resources; or the objective to attain a greater sales volume has to be balanced with the concern to reduce losses from bad debts. If your marketing is customer-oriented and is conducted in an integrated manner, you will have a better chance of attaining in the long run your company’s profit and growth objectives.
Taking too much out of the business
You are earning a living by managing your own business but resist the temptation to withdraw too much from the business for personal expenses. Exercise fiscal discipline especially in the first years and in difficult times.
Few small firms can recover from a major setback. Your firm will have a better chance of weathering a crisis if you conserve your capital “for a rainy day”.
Too much success
Yes, too much success can create trouble for the small firm. The sales of your products have exceeded your expectations and you decide to expand or diversify into other businesses. You later find out that you cannot duplicate your earlier successes.
- Before deciding whether or not to expand your business, first analyze the reasons why you were successful in the past. You may have succeeded because you or your men had the special knowledge and skills for your particular business. But you may not have the competence to expand into a new business or run a bigger scale operation.
- Or you may have succeeded not because of your expertise but simply because you were lucky. The timing was right or there was no competition.
- Simply stated, grow according to your ability, your resources and external conditions affecting your firm.
Too much success, instead of generating overconfidence, may encourage complacency. After years of struggle your business becomes established and you may tend to relax. You continue to depend on the same management skills, the same products and processes for future growth and profits. Before long you become uncompetitive and other firms encroach on your market share. If you want to stay in business, you must realize that market conditions change very fast — new firms are coming in and new products, materials, processes and machinery are being developed. From biology, we learn that the organism that can adjust to changes in its environment is the organism that will survive and grow. This also holds true for business organizations.
Failure to delegate
Many firms remain small because their growth depends on what the owner can do himself. At the start when the business is very small, it is appropriate that the owner takes charge of all the operations. The need to delegate occurs when the firm is too large for one man to run but too small to afford a full team of managers. The failure to delegate is apparent when the owner-manager is bogged down in details; when he starts making costly mistakes he normally would not commit if he were not too busy. This inability to delegate is difficult to overcome because of the nature of the entrepreneur himself; the business is his “baby”; he would not like to share control over it with anybody else. But if the entrepreneur wants his business to survive, he simply must change his management s style when the situation requires it.
Why should you delegate? Delegating multiplies your power — you can do more things. It is a form of insurance — business can run smoothly even when you have to be absent. Some employees become more motivated when they are given more responsibility.
One way of avoiding this pitfall is to develop a strong second man, a top assistant. These guidelines can help you develop a good second man:
- Recruit one who has the qualifications and the potential to be your top assistant. You may need one who is strong where you are weak. Since hiring a top assistant is a key decision, consulting other people can help you make a good choice.
- Define clearly what your top assistant can do, share relevant information and skills, and get the other employees’ cooperation.
- Give a trial period during which you delegate responsibility gradually and the top assistant can prove his ability to help you and the firm.
- Reward your top assistant adequately, perhaps, even to the extent of sharing the profits or the business with him.
You can best avoid the pitfalls described above if you are both an entrepreneur and a manager. That is, if you know not only how to do things but also know how to get things done through other people; if you can reduce risks as well as take risks.
There are indeed many pitfalls besetting the entrepreneur’s way to profits, growth and self-fulfillment. But these pitfalls are in a sense an advantage to the true entrepreneur because these pitfalls will select and limit the number of entries into small-scale entrepreneurship.
CHARACTERISTICS OF GOOD ENTREPRENEURS
- Respected in their community
- Knowledgeable of various aspects of their operations (and strives to know even more)
- Prudent in asset acquisitions
- Good track record of borrowing experience
- Sensitive to opportunities and problems
- Live simple lifestyles
- Grow by manageable levels
CHARACTERISTICS OF BAD PROJECTS
- Technically unsound
- Poorly planned
- Very risky
- Weak financing package
- Poor management
- Wrong market mix
- Inadequate inputs
- Lack of competitive advantage
- Overambitious forecasts
- Disregard for real level of needs
- Dependence on subsidies/incentives
REASONS FOR BAD PROJECT DECISIONS
- Personal/emotional attachment to the project
- Involvement with prevalent political waves
- Pressure for quick results
- Ulterior motive of parties
- Disregard of local situation vs. “standards”
- Conflict between project interest and national programs
- Influence of inappropriate incentives or financial package
Bangladesh achieved a steady 5% growth rate of real gross domestic product (GDP) during the 1990s, as compared with 4% in the 1980s. In terms of US dollars, the value of GDP in current prices increased by 6.9 percent to US$60407 million in FY05 from US$56493 million in the previous year. The growth of per capita real GDP accelerated from 1.7% per annum in the 1980s to 3.1% in the 1990s. Per capita GDP stood at US$445 in FY05 against US$418 in the previous year. The growth in the 1990s was attributable to the reforms to move Bangladesh toward an open economy, such as making the currency convertible on the current account, reducing import duties, removing controls on the movements of foreign private capital, and introducing value-added tax. The Bangladesh economy became more closely integrated with the global economy, with its trade doubling over the 1990s to reach 31% of GDP by 2001. The industry and services sectors each contributed about 41%, and agriculture about 18%, to incremental GDP growth in the 1990s compared with the 1980s. Unlike the 1980s, when the rapid shift of labor into the rural nonfarm sector was largely in the form of self-employment, the 1990s witnessed the absorption of wage labor in greater numbers by relatively larger-scale enterprises. These enterprises were at the higher end of the productivity scale compared with the self-employed form of enterprises in the earlier years.1 Reflecting higher economic growth and increased employment generation, the poverty rate declined from 59% to 50% between 1991 and 2000.
The Government has progressively moved away from administered interest rates toward market-based rates. The disproportionately high interest rates offered by the National Savings Certificates2 that crowded out long-term borrowing by financial institutions (FIs) and private sector borrowers have been reduced toward closer alignment with comparable market rates. Despite these efforts, spreads between lending and deposit rates remain high due to the nonperforming loan (NPL) problem in the banking system, which is being addressed by the Government. The Government is also developing a market for government securities and significantly reduced the withholding tax on income from securities and bonds.3 On the foreign exchange market, the taka was floated in May 2003 and the exchange rate is managed flexibly, with interventions confined to countering disorderly conditions.
To maintain macroeconomic stability and implement structural reforms that will contribute to improving the investment climate, promoting economic growth, and reducing poverty, the Government has prepared the National Strategy for Economic Growth, Poverty Reduction, and Social Development, the Government’s interim poverty reduction strategy paper (I-PRSP), dated March 2003,4 which forms the basis for a 3-year arrangement with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) under the Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility (PRGF) originally approved for SDR347 million (about $505 million). The Government will have to accelerate economic growth to about 7% per year over the next decade to reduce poverty in half by 2015 in accordance with the Millennium Development Goals.5 In comparison, annual GDP growth was 5.3% in FY2003, 5.5% in FY 2004, and is projected at 5% for FY2005. The IMF PRGF target is 6% for FY2006–FY2008. The IMF PRGF together with the Development Support Credit I and II projects of the World Bank (WB) also provide policy support in the financial sector, including preparation for privatization of and management support for the nationalized commercial banks (NCBs) and issuance of prudential regulations. In July 2004, IMF completed the second review of Bangladesh’s economic performance under PRGF and approved a release of SDR49.5 million (about $72 million) as well as an augmentation of the PRGF, amounting to SDR53.33 million (about $78 million), for the Trade Integration Mechanism.
Uttara Bank Limited tries to give the best customer support, the have some lake and linkage compare to other bank of the same generation such as the way……..
- Employee may need advance training
- Policy may be revised from time to time
- Customized software may be implemented
The bank has to increase their advertisement and also increase their social activity
- The interest rate in Uttara Bank Limited is now 18%, which is very high for the customers. Interest rate should be reduced to attract more customers and raise the satisfaction level significantly.
- The employees of RFC especially the MIS division should be more cooperative with the customers over phone when applicants are looking for the necessary information.
- A new internal division can be opened for information deliver in RFC.
- HR should be more concerned about to train the sales team.
- The disburse time in the Uttara Bank Limited is very lengthy. It should be reduced and the customers should get their service at a shortest possible time.
- The application process time is very lengthy. The time required for the applications should be reduced as well.
- Debt burden ratio should be relaxed especially in case of highly potential and successful business personnel.
The specific and board recommendations of the study are as follows:
- The authority should recruit more employees to serve the customers. The can recruit experienced employee as well as fresh graduate.
- The bank should introduce more products based on the market demand.
- The bank should reduce their minimum balance to attract more customers.
- The salary of the worker need to be rise, as a result experienced people from other bank will be attract to join Uttara Bank Limited
- The bank can open more branches to reach to more customers.
- The bank can open branches or foreign booth because many people send money from abroad every year to Bangladesh.
- The bank should finance to the consumer goods, because many people in the country wants to buy consumer goods from bank loan.
- The marketing department of the bank should more efficient to reach at the hart of the customer.
- For the success of any organization, employee satisfaction is one of he most important factor and DBBL authority have to look about it.
- The bank should be more profit concern as well as took part to the economics development of the country.
- The departments of the bank should more efficient to make profit by satisfying customers.
- The bank should use printed instruments like cheque, pay orders etc.
- Being a clear transparent the bank can provide the best support to the customer as earn profit.
It is revealed from the above presentation that in 2010, the bank has achieved remarkable success in various financial activities as well as in bank’s business. During the year under report the bank has earned commendable operating profit and also attained capital adequacy. Substantial amount has been recovered from classified loan because of appropriate action in this regard.
UBL Bank contains an important part in overall operation of the Bank. Our industrial sector that are operating their business in different countries getting a good benefit from this department. Although there have some limitation in total operation process including online disturbance, management process, code fore, d authorization, technical problem etc. Bank now trying their best to improve such problem and to enhance their operation and customer services. For more facilities UBL bank have a good step to serve in rural areas. They made a deal with an ego, which facilitates them for more service in this sector. Moreover they have taken steps to open more branches in different area for wide operation. Due to clear and transparent operation bank have introduces Corporate Governance where board reviews and approves various policies for compliance by the management. The Board/ Executive committee reviews the polices / guidelines issued by the Central Bank regarding operation of the Industry. The Board / executive committee of the board approves the credit proposal as per approved policy and Bangladesh Bank guidelines/regulations. Due to maintaining different level of transparency bank are now receiving more profit in every year.
Needless to mention that continuous support and extended by our valued clients, shareholders, sponsors, business associates and well wishes played a vital role behind these operating results and the Board of Directors express felicitation to them in this regard. New CEO has joined to existing team and in 25th silver jubilee celebration a new logo with utterly new concept is introduced. Consequently, the directors acknowledge with gratitude the valuable guidance and co-operation received from the Ministry of Finance, Bangladesh Bank and Securities and Exchanges Commissions. The directors place on record their depreciation for the dedicated services rendered by the executives, officers and staff members of the bank.
As borrower selection is the key to successful retail lending, Uttara Bank Limited should focus on the selection of true borrower. At the same time it must be taken into account that right borrower selection does not mean that Uttara Bank Limited has to adopt conservative lending policy but rather it means that compliance with the KYC or Know Your Customer to ascertain the true purpose of the loan.
Uttara Bank Limited is bank of new generation. Though I tried to include at my report about deposit, customer service and general banking, I followed their rules and regulation and tried to use them in my report to prepare this report with my best effort.
Though all departments and sections are covered in the internship program, it is not possible to go to depth of each activities of branch because of time limitation. Bank is an institution, which acts as a financial intermediary. Since bank collect deposit from various source by paying interest to them and grant loan to some other parties at high rate to interest then the interest paid to the depositor, the differences between the two interests is termed as the profit.
Since Uttara Bank Ltd. Credit limit increased by taka 9907 core or 18.10% to tk. 64553.10 core during 2008-2009 as compared to increase of 10.30% in the preceding year, Uttara bank Ltd. Should pay more attention to loan and advance which not only increase it’s profit position but also alleviate poverty level of Bangladesh by providing loan to the capital seeker, increase standards of living.
- Commercial Banking Operations in Bangladesh
- Islamic Banking Concept Objectives and Basic Features
- Analysis of Loan Disbursement and Recovery Status
- Marketing Strategy of Islami Bank Bangladesh Ltd
- Electronic Banking in Dutch Bangla Bank Limited
- Customer Satisfaction on Credit Card Services Provided by Brac Bank