The main objective of this report is to analysis Loan classification, Provisioning policies, Risk management framework and Recovery strategies of Eastern Bank Limited. Other objectives are to know about factor influencing in credit decision and to know about the function of credit risk management. Also describe process of monitoring credit and Credit risk rating. Finally make a SWOT analysis of the bank’s overall performance on the basis of the experiences shared during the rotation period and give acclamation.
OBJECTIVE OF THE REPORT
The main objective of this internship report was to get a practical exposure to credit Payment System of Eastern Bank Limited and the roles the commercial banks playing in this area. Besides, this repot will was meant to revolve around some specific objectives. Such as:
- To provide a brief idea about the functions of the various departments.
- To make a SWOT analysis of the bank’s overall performance on the basis of the experiences shared during the rotation period and give acclamations, if any.
- Learning the system of credit payment by Eastern Bank Limited.
- Factor influencing in credit decision.
- To know about the function of credit risk management.
- To know the process of monitoring credit.
- To know about the Credit risk rating.
SOURCES OF DATA
- Primary sources of data: Direct conversation with the employees of Eastern Bank Limited.
- Secondary Sources of data: Annual Reports of the bank, different reports, operational manual for the employees, Bangladesh Bank Circulars, Bank Database and various other publications and websites.
- For understanding the procedure of banking operations, the author had observed the operations and worked with the officers at the same time. He had interviewed the EBL Officials for getting more information.
- For the analysis part, data have been collected from the loan proposals and other documentation packages of the bank.
Overview of the Bank
History and Background of Eastern Bank Limited
The emergence of Eastern Bank in the private sector is an important event for the banking industry in Bangladesh. In 1991, when the Bank of Credit and Commerce International (Overseas) BCCI had collapsed internationally, the operation of this bank had been closed down in Bangladesh. Taking into account, the welfare of the BCCI employees and its depositor’s interest, the Bangladesh Bank, under the Reconstruction Scheme, then gave permission to form a bank named Eastern Bank Limited, which would take over all the assets, cash and liabilities of BCCI in Bangladesh, with effect from 16th August 1992. Thus Eastern Bank Limited started functioning as a public limited company on August 8, 1992 with the objective to carry out banking business in and outside of Bangladesh
It started its business as a scheduled bank with only four branches, which included Principal Branch and Motijheel Branch in Dhaka, Agrabad Branch in Chittagong and another branch in Khulna.In July1993, when the bank got its Authorized Dealership from Bangladesh Bank, then it started its expansion of branches. Six and three new branches were opened in 1994 and 1995 respectively. The very next year they inaugurated two more branches. At present, it has twenty-two branches, which are scattered, all over the major cities of the country in major business areas.
It started its operational activities initially with an authorized capital of TK 1000 million, divided into 10 million shares of TK 100 each and paid up capital of Tk. 310 million.
At 2002, the paid up capital stood at TK 720 million but the authorized capital remained unchanged at Tk 1000 million. The general public held 83.42 % of its shares while institutional investors held the rest. At present EBL is one of the fastest growing commercial banks in the country and the largest capital based bank in Bangladesh. As of December 2005 its paid up capital was TK 828 million.
The initial shareholders were the National Commerical Banks, various government agencies and some of the depositors who had agreed to accept shares in the new bank in lieu of their deposits. The first Board of Directors of EBL constituted under government supervision, consisted of seven directors from various business and professions. Eastern Bank Limited was under government control until the end of 2000 and therefore there were alot of deficiencies in management. In 2001, the board of directors bought in new professional management from various foreign banks who have been trying to modernize the bank ever since. At present Mr. M Ghaziul Haque and Mr. K. Mahmood Sattar are heading Eastern Bank Limited as the Chairman and Managing Director respectivefully
EBL Vision is to become the Bank of Choice by transforming the way it does business and developing a truly unique financial institution that delivers superior growth and financial performance and be the most recognizable Brand in the financial services in Bangladesh.
EBL dreams to be the bank of choice of the general public, which includes both the consumer and the corporate clients. They want to build such an image that whenever people think of a bank, they will think of Eastern Bank. They have introduced state of the art banking technology, which has made banking easier and hassle-fee for all. It has adopted the tag line “Simple math, the philosophy of easy banking” and has changed its logo to reflect the changes that are taking place in EBL.
In order to achieve superior growth and financial performance for its shareholders, EBL is radically transforming the way it does business. The bank has already restructured from the traditional geographic matrix (branch based banking) to business unit matrix. The bank is also centralizing most of the business functions in the head office to ensure greater control and efficiency.
In line with its vision EBL has developed a mission statement, which reads as follows:
- We will deliver service excellence to all our customers, both internal and external
- We will constantly challenge our systems, procedures and training to maintain a cohesive and professional team in order to achieve service excellence
- We will create an enabling environment and embrace a team based culture where people will excel
- We will ensure to maximize shareholder’s value
Present Business Philosophy
The philosophy of the present management of EBL is to develop the bank into an ideal and unique banking institution. EBL wants to be different from other privately owned commercial banks operating in Bangladesh. They want to be a leader in the industry rather then being a follower. They want to be a leader in providing quality service to customers so that customers can get something additional from their services.
Till 2000, EBL operated in a Geographical Matrix, where the business of the bank was concentrated on the twenty-two branches divided into zones. But in 2001, the new management led by the Managing Director, Mr. Mahmood Sattar changed the geographic matrix structure of EBL into Business Matrix structure. The bank has been restructured into three main businesses, which are responsible for earning the incomes of the bank, These are:
- Corporate Banking
- Consumer Banking
- Treasury Banking
All other departments of the bank act as support units for these three units and help them in every possible way. Under this arrangement, the responsibilities and function of the branches have been reduced dramatically. Many of the activities like credit evaluation and approval, monitoring of loans, trade services etc are now centralized in the Head Office. The branches of the bank are termed now as the “Sales and Service Centers” whose primary focus is on delivering services to corporate and consumer clients and building and maintaining relationship with them
EBL’s primary objectives are the following:
- To maintain a satisfactory deposit mix
- To grow its credit extension service to corporate as well as individual customers
- To increase its diversification of loan portfolio and geographical coverage
- To reduce present operating expenses further so as to increase earnings before tax
- To reduce the burden of non-performing assets.
Like every other business organization, the top management makes all the major decisions. The board of directors being at the highest level of organizational structure plays an important role in policy formulation, but it is not directly concerned with the day-day operations of the bank. They have delegated this duty to the management committee. The board mainly establishes the objectives and policies of the bank. There are three committees of the board for different purposes.
They are the following:
- Executive committee comprising of seven members of the board.
- Committee of the board for Administrative purpose
- Committee to examine Bad Loan cases
The Chief Executive Officer (CEO) who is assisted by three Executive Vice-presidents (EVPs) looks after the day-to-day affairs of the Bank. Human Resources Department, Managing Director’s Secretariat and Audit and Compliance Department are under direct control of the CEO. The three Executive Vice President are in charge of Operations, Credit and Corporate Banking respectively. They control the affairs of these departments through the managers who are in charge of various departments under these divisions.
Mid and lower level employees get the direction and instruction from the top executives about the duties and tasks they have to perform. The chief executive provides the guideline and broad direction to the managers and employees, but delegates responsibility for determining how tasks and goals are to be accomplished.
Division of EBL
All policy formulations and its execution are carried out at the head office. There are eleven major divisions in EBL, which are the following:
a) Corporate Banking Division
b) Credit Risk Management and Administration
c) Consumer Banking Division
d) Brand Management Division
e) Trade Services Division
f) International Division
g) Human Resources Division
h) Information Technology Division
i) Audit and Compliance Division
j) Finance and accounts Division
k) Special Asset Management Division
Services of Corporate Banking:
- Structuring of Facilities for Corporate customers.
- Providing Financial Solutions
- Advisory Services
- Arrange Loan Syndications
- Developing Relationship between the Clients and the Bank
- Processing credit and other approvals for credit and other facilities. Provides a one stop service for Credit facilities.
- Handles pricing issues and Wallet Sizing Exercises to maximizes the earnings of the Bank as well as of the Client
- Coordinating service delivery of all EBL distribution channels (Sales and Service
centers, Trade Services, Treasury, Credit issues as required for the customer.
- Ensures corporate customer’s complaints are addressed.
- Relationship Teams of EBL are available to serve you.
The main functions of this division are as follows:
- Targeting corporate clients and building business relationships with them
- Designing customized service for the clients
- Evaluating financial strength of the client
- Making possible recommendations for further expansion
Credit Risk Management and Administration
The main objective of this division is to evaluate the credit worthiness and debt payment capability of the present customers and loan applicants. The respective branches send all loans and advances proposals from the prospective borrowers to the Head Office Credit Risk Management (HOCRM) for approval. If this department finds the loan proposal attractive, it either approves it or sends it to the board for approval. It is responsible also for setting prices for credit facilities given to clients and ensuring that it is being implemented in the branches. This department also monitors the various loan accounts of the branches and prepares various statements for Bangladesh Bank.
The main responsibilities of the Credit Risk Management functions are:
- Oversee the bank’s credit policies, procedures and controls relating to all credit risks arising from corporate/commercial/institutional banking, personal banking, & treasury operations
- Approve risk transactions within their delegated authority and advise on credits which exceed such limits
- Ensure implementation of credit facilities through an independent Credit administration function
- Implement review and control policies on all lending portfolios
- Manage individual problem credits and monitor the distressed assets portfolio within EBL’s risk parameters
- Recommend provisions for loan losses complying central banks rules and norms
- Review lending programs and provide recommendations for approval.
The Credit Risk Management Department is assisted by the Credit Administration Department, who is primary concerned with the post- approval functions of the division. Credit Administration critically tracks and monitors the following:
- Credit expiry
- Past dues
- Excess over limit
- Document deficiency
Credit Administration is involved in basically two broad functions:
- Loan Monitoring
The most important aspects of this part are:
- Follow approval terms
- Proper loan disbursement
- Monitor interest payment
- Monitor Principal repayment
- Balance with general ledger
The important functions of this part are:
- Look at sanction terms
- Fill up loan documentation checklist
- Ensure Proper loan documentation
- Obtain client sign off
- Filing with the Registered Joint Stock Corporation (RJSC)
- Registered mortgage deed execution
Consumer Banking Division
The consumer banking division deals with the financial needs of all the individual customers of the bank. The consumer banking activities are being carried out through the twenty-two branches of Eastern Bank Limited operating countrywide. Among these branches ten branches are located in Dhaka, five in Chittagong, three in Sylhet and one each in Khulna, Jessore, Bogra and Rajshahi. Previously these branches used to conduct all kind of business activities, including processing credit issue, conducting trade service, consumer service etc. But after the restructing process, all the branches are now mainly focusing only on delivering service to individual customers. EBL before did not have many attractive consumer products. However, Ebl has decided to give more focus on consumer banking and is developing modern delivery channels like ATMs, telebanking, internet banking, credit cards etc and many other new consumer products and services to meet specific financial demands of the customer as well as to make their life easy and convenient.
The main functions of this division are:
- Settlement of accounts
- Building strong relationship with individual customers
- Identifying individual needs of the customer and thus helping design products that will meet their need
- Providing locker services
- Providing ancillary services.
- Providing consumer loans
Small and Medium Enterprises (SME) in Bangladesh contributed 25% of gross domestic product (GDP) and 80% of the industrial jobs of the country in 2004. According to ADB, the country’s estimated 6 million SMEs and micro enterprises firms of less than 100 employees have a significant role in generating growth and jobs. This is a sector that has its own distinct needs and requires specialized focus. Eastern Bank Ltd. (EBL) has launched SME Banking in early 2005 with this view in mind.
” Provide SMEs with easy access to financing.
” Deliver products that ensure superior returns to our customers.
” Orient customers with industry trends, regulatory issues etc, for their success.
” Value long term relationship banking.
SME Banking is an integrated specialized area of the Bank, which addresses the diverse financial needs of Small and Medium Enterprises.
Local Business Houses (Private Limited Companies), Sole Proprietorship Concerns, Partnerships etc are considered to be our SME Customers. Services provided by SME Banking are as follows:
- Structuring of Facilities for SME Customers.
- Develops understanding of customer businesses and advises Financial Solutions
- Developing Relationship between the Clients and the Bank
- Processing credit facility requirements and arranging approvals for credit facilities.
- Handles pricing issues and Wallet Sizing Exercises to maximizes the earnings of the Bank as well as of the Client
- Ensures SME customers’ complaints and Service issues are promptly addressed.
- Coordinates activities of support unit Credit Administration unit which prepares security documentation, security registration, and CIB related issues.
The SME banking comprises two different segments, Small and Medium segments.
Brand Management Division
Although EBL is in the banking business for quite sometime its brand image has not grown strong and in order to succeed in the competitive bank environment it needs to enrich its brand equity. So far EBL has shunned any sort of promotional tools except for a few inconspicuous billboard advertisements, signboards and newspaper recruitment advertisement. However a new department called “Brand Management” has been set up in 2001 to give a new and enhanced brand identity to EBL. This department supervises the planning of advertisement campaigns for EBL’s products and analyzing customer feedbacks. With the aid of an advertising agency the logo and stationary of EBL has been changed and eye-catching brochures, calendars and posters have been prepared which are displayed at the sales & service centers.
Trade service division
Trade services are a major operational department of EBL. It deals with issues regarding to export, import and guarantees. It performs the job of financing and facilitating foreign trade. There are separate units operating within the trade services department in EBL. Those are:
The major functions of Trade Services include the followings:
- Issuance of Letter of Credit
- Advising of Letter of Credit
- Negotiating documents
- Collection of Payments
- Facilitating trade by arranging loans to cater different needs of the clients
International Division is responsible for assisting the authorized branches to deal in foreign trades, that is import and export business on account of the customers of the bank by giving approval for transactions and controlling them at various stages. It deals with all correspondents of foreign banks having arrangement with the bank
The functions performed by this division are as follows:
- Carrying out correspondent banking relationship
- Supervising of foreign exchange transaction of other units
- Supervising sale/ purchase of foreign currencies
Human Resources Division
The employees are Eastern Banks most valuable resource. Having competent and professional employees is becoming increasingly important in today’s competitive world and EBL has a significant competitive advantage in this respect. Many of its employees have worked here since the BCCI time and therefore have vast experience in their respective fields. New employees are recruited with sound academic background and wherever needed proper training is given to the employees after recruitment to equip them for their responsibilities.
The Mission of Human Resource division (HR) is to make EBL the Employer of Choice. The main functions of the division are:
Building Employer Image: The HR department has taken steps in building relationship with recognized educational institutes in order to create positive awareness about EBL as an employer. They have done this by extending internships to students, sponsoring student events and by participating in job fairs run by different universities.
Staffing: Another important task of the HR division is to prepare all formalities regarding appointment and joining of the successful candidates.
Training: HR department emphasizes on training and developing their employees through various training programmes held at the Bank’s own Training Center at Shantinagar and various outside locations, like Bangladesh Institute of Bank Management to enhance the skills of their employees, to help them deal better with their job responsibilities
Performance Appraisal of Employees: The employees of EBL are given an annual target performance based on a discussion between the employee and his or her supervisor. At year-end, a performance evaluation called Annual Classified Report (ACR) is carried out based on the target. Increments, bonuses and promotions are given to EBL employees based on this performance evaluation.
Information Technology Division
Previously, Eastern Bank had a very low level of automation. But in 2001, when the new management took over, they gave huge emphasis on computerizing the bank’s operations. After two years, almost all the operations in the bank are now automated. The Bank is also shifting to a new IT platform, which aims at maintaining, operating and strengthening the technology base of the bank, to enable error free production of information that ensures ongoing efficiency and profitability of operation. A world class banking software called Flex Cube has been installed which will centralize operations and provide Online Banking, Internet Banking, Automated Teller Machine, Telephone Banking and credit card facility etc.
With this implementation of state-of-the-art Information Technology, the IT division has become an important contributor to the bank’s overall efficiency and profitability. At present the IT department serves the following functions:
- Development of software for banks operation according to need, their maintenance and purchase of new software
- Maintenance of computer hardwares and upgrading the PCs whenever required
- Training the staff so that they can perform on the automated environment
- Troubleshooting with the new software
Audit and Compliance Division
The main function of this division is to provide legal assistance to the branches and to ensure strict adherence of rules and policies by all concerned officials of the bank through routine and surprise inspection and audit. The functions of this division are as follows:
- Implementing rescheduling process of stuck up loan to the branches for obtaining repayment schedule through strong persuasion and serve final notice as the condition required.
- Monitoring the individual cases with respect to their securities, value of securities and finally review of possibility of recovery of bank’s stuck-up classified loan
- Investigating suspicious or irregular matters being directed by higher management and being requested by branch in charges too
- Time to time follow up of stuck- up-advances of branches and keeping the branches under constant pressure
- Inspecting all branches operations at least once in a year
- Carrying out surprise audit as felt necessary
Finance and accounts division
The finance and accounts division is important for any bank because its task is to
- Maintain daily liquidly position, treasury bills, call money etc
- Monthly-accrued interest calculation of all interest-bearing accounts and amortization of all fixed and other assets
- Preparation of statement of accounts and profit and loss account for the bank and annual report of the bank
- Weekly deposit and advance analysis of the bank
- Cost of fund analysis.
Special Asset Management Division
Special Asset Management (SAMD) deals with all the classified accounts in the bank loan portfolio, mainly accounts which have fallen into substandard, doubtful and loss category. The responsibilities of the Special Asset Management Department are the following:
- Monitoring and controlling the classified accounts through monthly reporting and quarterly review
- Actively follow up with borrower for recovery
- Negotiating and restructuring debts wherever feasible on its own and in association with the concerned relationship manager
- Preparing a consolidated report of all bad loans written off on a quarterly basis and submitting the report to the head of credit risk management and Managing Director and CEO.
This department looks after the administrative matters and supply of all tangible goods to the branches. Some of the main functions of the division are as follows:
- Make arrangement for branch opening such as making lease agreement, internal decorations etc
- Print all security papers and bank stationery
- Purchase stationery items and distribute it to the branches
- Advertise in the different media about tender notice, general meetings and public interest
Strengths of the Bank
The strengths of the bank are the following:
- Changed Organizational Structure: Up till 2000, EBL carried out its operation like every other local bank. All of its branches acted as single banks and did everything from marketing to loan processing to relationship maintaining. In 2001 EBL changed its traditional way of doing business. Rather than operating as a geographical matrix, EBL started operating as a business matrix. The functional areas were separated and redefined as business units. This has allowed management to operate more efficiently.
- Centralized Processes: The new organizational culture has resulted in centralized processes. Before the branches were empowered to do almost everything within limits. They were responsible for marketing, loan processing, account activity monitoring and other transactions. Their accountability did not go beyond sending statements to the head office annually. Under the current system management has more control on the overall bank and its day-to-day operations. As a result loan defaults have been lower because the Corporate Division and the Risk Management Division, at Head Office, scrutinize the loan proposals along with the branch managers
- Superior IT Platform: From 15 March 2003, EBL has started using Flex cube- a banking software, which caters to all the needs of retailer, corporate, treasury and investment Banking. Flex cube enables EBL to remain associated between all its branches and business units.
- The functional structure of the Bank has made the structure flat that has facilitated decentralization among the functional division. As a result, the decision-making procedure has become quick. Moreover, the management has greater control over the activities of the Bank.
Weakness of the Bank
The weaknesses of the bank are the following:
- In the new structure, each functional division is tall within the division and delegation of authority is also centralized. It has a significant effect over the whole institution because middle and lower level employees are becoming more frustrated as they are loosing their decision making power.
- As the organization is moving towards semi-multinational culture, some employees are resisting the change as they are accustomed with traditional banking system and do not want to change.
- Unimpressive Physical Layout: The physical layouts of several of the EBL branches are quite unappealing. Some are located at inconspicuous locations with dull premises. The interiors of Principal and Head Office are not properly decorated. These features of the Bank may create wrong impression in the customers mind, especially the ones who come for the first time.
Threats of the Bank
The following are the threats of the bank:
- Technological Obsolence: EBL has started using a very modern and sophiscated IT platform. The bank plans to change its entire business philosophy based on the uniqueness of this product and ancillary infrastructure. However, like every other novelty, this system has the risk of being obsolete as technological changes are coming very quickly and continuously.
- It faces constant threat from other local and multinational banks that are continuously trying to come up quickly with more new innovative products that appeals to customers first.
Opportunities of the Bank
The following are the opportunities for the bank:
- Day by day many banks are providing evening service to their customers. EBL can make necessary arrangements to implement it.
- Now a days many banks have introduced Islamic banking. Starting Islamic banking section can be an effective tool to grab the potential market segment.
Financial Ratio Analysis of Eastern Bank Limited
Conducting the financial ratio analysis is important for any bank, because it helps us to measure its performance, that is how adequately a bank meets the objectives of its shareholders (owners), employees, depositors and other creditors and other borrowing customers. So to get an overall picture of the performance of Eastern Bank Limited, it’s financial ratio analysis have been carried out in the following section.
Return on Assets:
The return on assets is an indicator of a banks managerial efficiency. It indicates how capable the management of the bank has been in converting the banks assets into net earnings ie how much profit a company is able to generate for each dollar of asset invested.
Return on Assets = Net Income after Taxes/ Total Assets
|Net Income After Taxes||357,771,944||483,365,229||546,515,028|
From chart it can be observed that from Year 2003 to Year 2004 the return on assets had increased for Eastern Bank Limited. This indicates that the managers were efficient in converting the banks assets into net earnings. From Year 2004 to 2005 the ROA on investment decreases slightly, because the rate of increase of net income after taxes from 2004 to 2005 is less then the rate of increase of net income after tax from 2003 to 2004. The net profit in 2004- 2005 was slighty lower because the operating expenses of the bank went up, the salary and employee allowances were increased, while at the same time the bank spent a large amount of its money on business development, awareness of brand building, in the mass market of EBL’s product and services using electronic and print media. Overall from 2003- 2005 the ROA has increased which indicates that the company has been able to generate more profit for each dollar of asset invested.
Return on Equity:
The return on equity measures the rate of return flowing to the banks shareholder. It measures the net benefit that the stockholders have received from investing their capital in the financial firm.
Return on Equity = Net Income after Taxes/Total equity capital
|Net Income After Taxes||357,771,944||483,365,229||546,515,028|
From the above chart it can be seen that from Year 2003-2004 the ROE of EBL increased. This was because the rate of increase of net profit after taxes was high from 2003 to 2004. The wages did not increase substantially from 2003- 2004, the advertising costs did not increase so much, because aggressive advertising was not being carried out and other expenditures of the bank did not increase so significantly, so net profit increased rapidly from 2003-2004. But from 2004-2005 the operating costs increased significantly because of increase in salaries and allowances, increase in advertising and other expenditures, causing the rate of increase of net profit after tax to increase slightly.
Net Interest Margin:
The net interest margin measures how large a spread between interest revenues and interest cost management has been able to achieve by close control over earning assets and the pursuit of the cheapest sources of funding. The net interest margin is calculated using the following formula:
Net Interest Margin= (Interest income- Interest Expense)/Total asset
|Interest income (a)||1,682,551,683||1,894,252,122||2,373,288,995|
|Interest expense (b)||928,450,655||949,203,013||1,365,455,642|
|(Interest income – Interest expense) (c)||754,101,028||945,049,109||1,007,833,353|
|Total asset (d)||18,715,628,398||23,047,667,908||27,399,954,469|
From the above chart we can see that the net interest margin has increased slightly from 2003- 2004. It has increased from year 2003-2004 because the rate of increase of interest revenue is higher relative to rate of increase of the interest expenses during the year. From 2004-2005 both interest revenue and interest expense has increased, but the interest expense has increased proportionately more then interest revenue, causing the net margin to dip slightly in value. Overall we can say that the management has been efficient in controlling revenue and expense cost since the net interest margin has not fluctuated so much, with slight deviation from one year to another
Net Non interest margin:
The net non interest margin measures the amount of noninterest revenue stemming from deposit service charges and other service charges the financial firm has been able to collect (called fee income) relative to the amount of noninterest costs incurred (including salaries and wages, repair and maintenance of facilities and loan loss expenses). The net non-interest revenue is calculated using the following formula:
Net Non interest margin: (Noninterest revenues- Noninterest expenses)/Total assets
|Noninterest revenue (a)||302,271,256||347,052,574||583,776,899|
|Noninterest expense (b)||297,600,339||399,670,759||535,794,924|
|Total asset (c)||18,715,682,398||23,047,667,908||27,399,954,469|
|Net Non Interest Margin= (a-b)/c||0.025%||-0.22%||0.18%|
From the above table it can be seen that in 2003 net non-interest margin was positive. In 2004 it became negative whereas it increased and became positive again in 2005. Net-non interest margin was positive in 2003 because the non-interest revenue exceeded the interest expense. In 2004, the rate of increase of non- interest revenue was at a much slower pace then the rate of increase of non-interest expense causing the non-interest expense to exceed the non-interest revenue and eventually the net non -interest margin to be negative. Non
interest revenue increased because the firms operating expenses went up significantly. It implies that the bank was inefficient in controlling its noninterest expenses. In 2005 net non interest margin showed signs of increasing because the bank focused more on increasing its fee based income and service charges as a result its noninterest revenue exceeded the noninterest expense causing the net non interest margin to be positive and to be increasing.
Net operating margin:
The net operating margin measures how efficient the management has been in ensuring that its revenue grows faster then its rising costs. The net operating margin is calculated using the following formula:
Net operating margin: (Total operating revenue- Total operating expense)/Total assets
|Total operating revenue||1,056,372,284||1,292,101,683||1,591,610,252|
|Total operating expense (b)||297,600,339||399,670,759||535,794,924|
|Total asset (c)||18,715,682,398||23,047,667,908||27,399,954,469|
|Net operating margin=(a-b)/c||4.05%||3.87%||3.85%|
EBL has a decreasing trend in net operating margin from 2003 to 2004, with neglible decrease from 2004-2005. This is because during this period although the net interest margin increased, the net non interest margin decreased and became negative causing the net operating margin which is the combination of net interest margin and net non interest to decrease. In 2004-2005, although the net interest margin decreased from 2004 to 2005, but the net non-interest margin increased from being negative in 2004 to be positive in 2005, causing the net operating margin to decrease very slightly.
Asset Utilization Ratio:
The asset utilization measures the efficiency of the management in managing the company’s asset, so as to obtain more operating revenue for the company. The asset utilization ratio is calculated using the following formula:
Asset Utilization Ratio= Operating revenue/Total assets
|Total operating revenue(a)||1,056,372,284||1,292,101,683||1,591,610,252|
|Total asset (b)||18,715,682,398||23,047,667,908||27,399,954,469|
|Asset utilization ratio||5.64%||5.60%||5.80%|
From 2003-2005 the asset utilization ratio in Ebl has been decreasing slightly with increase from 2004- 2005. This suggests that management has started to utilize its assets better to get higher yield from those assets.
The equity multiplier measures how many dollars of assets can be supported by each dollar of equity (owners capital) and therefore how much of the firms assets must rely on debts. The equity mutiplier is calculated using the following ratio:
Equity multiplier = Total assets/Total equity capital
|Total Assets (a)||18,715,682,398||23,043,468,479||27,396,601,059|
|Total equity capital(b)||2,320,898,168||2,630,624,772||3,070,915,605|
|Equity multiplier= a/b||8.06x||8.75x||8.92x|
The equity multiplier of EBL has not increased so much from 2003 to 2005. It implies that the equity financing of the bank has increased slightly over the years and the bank has relied more on debt financing to finance its asset. There is less equity to finance the assets as a result there is less chance of failure risk on the part of the bank. The less the risk, the less the potential for high returns to the stockholders.
Earning spread measures the effectiveness of the bank’s intermediate function in burrowing and lending money and also the intensity of competition in the bank’s market areas. Earning spread is calculated using the following ratio:
Earning spread= (Total Interest Income – Total Interest Expenses)/(Total Earning Asset-Total Interest Bearing Liabilities)
|Interest income (a)||1,682,551,683||1,894,252,122||2,373,288,995|
|Earning asset (b)||14,899,341,367||19,372,147,401||22,766,465,066|
|Total interest expense (c)||928,450,655||949,203,013||1,365,455,642|
|Total interest bearing liabilities(d)||9,470,899,794||12,471,732,216||16,572,184,346|
The earning spread of EBL is slightly increasing although the ongoing competition in the banking sector, which is the emergence of new banks, have decreased the earning spread of many banks. The bank has been able to earn slightly more income from its loan and advances then the interest rate, it has paid on the deposit to its customers, causing the earning spread to increase slightly from 2003-2004 with being more or less being stable from 2004-2005. It implies that the bank costs of fund- the interest rate that it has given to its customers on its deposits is slightly less then the revenue it has been able to generate from the loan and advances it has given out.
Products and Services Offered by EBL
Categories of SerVices of Eastern Bank Limited:
Eastern Bank Limited is capable of handling all the banking needs of customers and is always available to provide personalized one-stop services. The services are customized and confidential. The different categories of services that EBL offers are as follows:
The Retail Banking Division comprises the domestic branch network with the specialized customer credit, real estate finance. Retail banking deals with the banking services to the individuals. Eastern Bank’s retail banking strategy is aimed at keeping as closely in tune with their customers’ needs as possible and further improving the quality of advisory services. As a result, EBL offers different product ranges to different target groups. It includes the following;
- Deposits Services: Individuals may open current, savings, STD, fixed deposit accounts.
- Wage Earners Services: EBL offers a few innovative schemes to Bangladeshi wage earners working overseas.
Eastern Bank Limited offers various services to foreign mission, NGOs and voluntary organization, consultants, airlines, shipping lines, contractors, schools, colleges, universities, donor agencies and consultants.
The services include the following:
- Deposit services
- Current accounts in both Taka and major foreign currencies.
- Convertible Taka accounts
- Local and foreign currency remittances.
- Various types of financing to cater to the banking requirements of multinational clients.
A professional account management team caters to the needs to corporate clientele and provides a comprehensive range of financial services to national and multinational companies. Its services include:
- Corporate deposit accounts
- Projects finance investment, constancy and other finances.
- Syndicated loans.
- Local and international treasury products.
- Bonds and guarantees.
- Skilled and responsive attention to varying lending needs.
Being a commercial Bank EBL provides comprehensive banking services to all types of commercial concerns. Some of the services are:
- Trade finance
- Issuing of import L/Cs.
Advising and confirming export L/Cs.
- Bonds and guarantees.
- Investment advice.
- Project finance opportunities for import substitution and export oriented project.
Leasing: It is a very flexible arrangement, which is tailored to suit most requirements of its clients. Lease financing by Eastern Bank is a unique means of funding a firm’s need for capital equipment without actually lending to the firm.
Services to correspondent banks include:
- Current accounts services where settlement is necessary.
- Issue bonds and guarantees in support of their customer business.
Advise letter of credit and negotiation of documents.
Market intelligence and status report.
Products and Services offered by EBL
Easter Bank Limited is a commercial bank, which has to operate under the rules and regulations of Bangladesh Bank for schedule commercial banks. It has highly skilled and qualified professional staffs, which are capable of handling all the banking needs. An officer who is responsible for all activities done in that department specially supervises each section. Its services are personalized and backed by a poor level of automation.
Services Offered by the Bank
The business of bank is to provide financial services to customers. Their goodwill and trust alone have made the banking industry a pillar of strength in society. The future growth of the banking industry and its profitability depends on customer satisfaction. EBL provides various financial services. In addition, some special services are offered that helps the bank to keep pace with competitive market.
Eastern Bank around twenty four credit products, of which twenty are funded and four non-funded. It is observed that only few products are marketed with particular fascination on overdraft and cash credit which are supposed to be a very high-risk product and least effective from control point of view. Efforts should be made to sell other products keeping in mind customer’s need and in line with their cash flow cycle and thereby ensure effective credit monitoring.
LIST OF CREDIT PRODUCTS OF EASTERN BANK LIMITE
|NAME||DESCRIPTION||PURPOSE||RISK FACTOR||TENOR/ VALIDITY|
|PAD||iPayment Against Document.||iAdvance Against Sight L/C|
|iRecourse on Title to Import Document.||i21Days per Bangladesh Bank.|
|*Cash Credit Against Hypothecation of Inventory and Book Debts.||iTo Finance Inventory.|
iOther Business Operations.
|Recourse on Sales.|
|iCash Credit Against Pledge of Inventory and Hypothecation of Inventor.||iTo Finance Pledge Inventory.||Recourse on Pledge Inventory.|
High Monitory Risk.
|ACCEPTANCE||iAcceptance Against ULC.||To Finance Assets throughu Banker’s Acceptance.||Recourses on Sales.||12Months.|
|OAP||iOwn Acceptance Purchase.||iTo Refinance Banks Acceptance.|
|LBPD||iLocal Bill Purchased.||iTo Purchase/Discount Against .Loan.|
iUpfront Interest to be Realized.
|iRecourses on Banks thru Acceptance.|
iResidual on Client.
|LAFBD||iLoan Against Foreign Bill Documentary.||iTo Purchase/Discount Export Doc, Against Export Contract Sight/ Usance.|
iUpfront Interest to be Realized (diff in FX Rate).
|iRecourse on export Doc.|
Residual on Client.
|SLC||iSight Letter of Credit.||iFor Importation.||iRecourse on Title to Import|
|ULC||iUsance Letter of Credit.||iFor importation.||iRecourse on Sales.||i12Months|
| *Letter of Guarantee.|
|iFor Contractual Obligation.||*Performance Risk.|
|PC||iPacking Credit Against Export L/C& Export Order.||iTo Finance Export L/C.|
iLien on Export L/C.
|SOD||iSecured Overdraft.||iGeneral Purposes.||i100% Cash Covered.|
*No Credit Risk.
|OD||iOverdraft Against Other Collateral||iGeneral purposes||iHigh Credit Risk|
iRecourse on Sales
|iImport Loan Against Hypothecation Inventory and Book Debts||iTo Finance Import L/C or Against Contract.|
|iRecourse on Sales.||i180 Day.|
|Import Loan (Pledge)||i Import loan Against Imported Merchandise Pledged and Hypothecation of Book Debts.||i To Finance Import L/C Merchandise under Pledged.||iRecourse on Pledge Inventory.|
iHigh Monitory Risk.
|Demand Loan (Hypo)||iDemand Loan Against Hypothecation of Inventory and Book Debts.||iTo Finance Inventory Procure Locally.|
iTo Finance Duty/Tax.
|iRecourse on Sales.||i180 Days.|
|Demand Loan (Pledge)||iDemand Loan Against Pledge Inventory Procedure Locally and Hypothecation of Book Debts.||iTo Finance Inventory Procure Locally under Pledge.|
|iRecourse on Pledge Inventory.|
iHigh Monitory Risk.
|Time Loan||iTime Loan Against Other Security||iTo Finance Fixed / other Asset.||iRecourse on Sales|
iCollateralize by Fixed /other Assets.
|Time Loan||iTime Loan Against Foreign Bill-Clean||iTo Finance Export Contract||iClean Finance|
|Term Loan||iTerm Loan Against|
|iTo Finance Fixed Assets.||iRecourse on Fixed Assets|
|iOver 12 Months.|
iMax 7 Years.
|iBankers Cheque Purchase (Foreign)||iTo Purchase /Discount Foreign Currency. ..Drafts/Payment Order.|
iUpfront Interest to be Realized.
|iRecourse on Banks.|
iResidual on Client.
|iBankers Cheque Purchase (Local).||iTo Purchase /Discount Bank Draft /Pay Order.|
iUpfront Interest to be Realized.
|iRecourse on Banks.|
iResidual on Client.
|Fwd FX||iForward Contract.||iCover Exchange Risk Against Letters of Credit.||iPerformance Risk.||i180 Days.|
Secured Overdrafts (SOD):
It is a continuous advance facility. By this agreement, the banker allows his customer to overdraft his current account up to his credit limits sanctioned by the bank. The interest is charged on the amount, which he withdraws, not on the sanctioned amount. MBL sanctions SOD against different
The processes of extending SOD are as follows –
- The party must have a current A/C with the branch.
- If the ownership of the firm is proprietorship, then a trade license must be submitted and in case of a limited company, all the documents required to open a current A/c should be submitted. The financial statements of the concerned firm should also be submitted.
- The party must maintain a good transaction with the branch and have a good turnover rate.
- The party will apply to the officer in charge of credit department (SME) of the branch for SOD arrangement.
- The concerned officer will prepare a “Credit Memorandum (CM)”, where he writes about the business concern, details of proprietors/ directors of the concern, management structure, the existing credit facilities, the particulars about the facilities that asked for-such as margin limit, date of expiry, details of security, and any other relevant information. Then the proposal is sent to the Head Office for approval.
- The credit risk management (CRM) department analyzes the proposal and scrutinizes all the factors regarding this proposal. If they are satisfied then they approves the proposal. The proposal is declined if this department thinks the applicant is not worthy to get loans. They sometimes approve the proposal with some additional conditions.
- Then the head office approval is sent to credit Administration department and this department is supposed to do the formalities regarding security documentation which are to be kept under banks custody.
- After all necessary documentation, this department issues two copies of sanction letter, one is given to client and another is kept with the Credit Admin department In both the sanction letter the client signs after accepting all the terms and conditions.
- If the client accepts all the conditions of the sanction letter and likes to avail the facility, then the amount sanctioned is loaded in a separate OD account. Now the client can avail this overdraft facility anytime from the bank.
Purchases & Discount of Bills:
Purchase and Discount of Bills is also a special form of advances, MBL normally purchase demand bills of exchange that are called “Drafts” accompanied by documents of title to goods such as Bill of Lading, Railway or Truck Receipt. The purchase of bills of exchange drawn at an issuance, i.e., for a certain period maturing on a future date and not payable on demand or sight is termed as discounting a bill and the charge recovered by Bank for this is called “Discount”.
The branch offers three types of Guarantee that are as follows:-
Tender or Bid Bond Guarantee:
The tender guarantee assures the tenderee that tenders shall uphold the conditions of his tender during the period of the offer as binding and that he / she will also sign the contract in the event of the order being granted.
A Performance guarantee expires on completion of the delivery or performance. Beneficiary finds that as a guarantee, the contract will be fulfilled in every respect and can retain the guarantee as per provision for loan time. This can be counteracted by including a clause stating that the supplier can claim under the guarantee, by presenting an acceptance certificate signed by the buyer.
This makes guarantee that the party will make payment after completion of the work
LOAN PROGRAMS/ SCHEMES:
The Bank provides Loans and Advance to Individual, Business entities group, Industries etc. It provides loan to both Trading and Manufacturing concern on Hypothecation and Pledge basis. Industrial loan also extended by the bank on Hire Purchase basis. Loan also provided by the bank for Foreign trade against imported materials and Confirmed L/C. Bank has two types of loan programs:
LOAN: Loan in the form of revolving credit and frequent Repayment and Adjustment.
ADVANCES: Loan in one shot disbursement and at a time repayment. The bank allows advanced on secured basis. Security and Collateral in the node of cash, quasi-cash and goods /real estates are taken by bank commonly.
BASIC INFORMATION OF LOAN:
Type(s) of Loan: Trade Finance, Finance against work order, Individual loans against security, Purchase of bills/Bill discounting, Letter of credit.
Amount of Loan: No minimum amount is fixed up. Amount is fixed on the basis of requirement.
Rate of Interest (Floating rate): Rate range from 14% to 17%.
- Normal client – 16%
- Special or valued client – 14%.
(Computed interest is charged on daily product basis and interest realized quarterly).
Term of Loan: 1-12 months, Loan can be adjusted earlier.
Mode of repayment:
Loans: Repayment is made any time in case of revolving credit.
Advances: The entire receivables including interest is repaid and adjusted at the end of term loan. No debit balance should be in the account.
Security/Collateral: Hypothecation / Pledge of raw materials, Stocks, Hypothecation of furniture, Fixture and machinery and other goods, Building and other immovable properties and DP note.
LOAN PROCESSING COST:
Application fees: No fee.
Documentation fee: Actual basis. Appraisal fee: 5% – 1% of the total loan sanctioned.
Legal fee: Examination and technical assistance fee (in case of project).
LOAN PROCESSING TIME:
It varies with the nature of loan – Trade finance – 1-2 weeks-Loan Proposals require BOD approval-3 weeks-Secured overdraft (SOD) – IF a third party issue the financial instrument than it may take more time. Otherwise, within a day by the manager .In case of a big amount of short term finance, if requires BOD approval and so, it may take even a month to sanction.
PAPER/ DOCUMENTS REQUIRED:
Security documentation includes Accepted sanction letter, Letter of continuity, Letter of Revival, Demand promissory note, Personal guarantee of the client, Letter of authority, Letter of lien, Trade license, Tax identification number, Business plan, Cash flow statement, Fund flow statement, Balance sheet, Income statement, etc.
Procedures for giving advances
EBL usually follows these steps for sanctioning any kind of advances as available with the branch-
The prospective borrower will submit a request letter to the branch for loan
After receiving the request letter, EBL sends a letter to Bangladesh Bank for obtaining a report from CIB (Credit Information Bureau). The purpose of the report is to being informed that whether the borrower has taken loan from any other bank(s); and if taken, whether these loans are calcified or not.
After receiving CIB report, if the bank thinks that the prospective borrower will be a good borrower, then the bank will scrutinize the document. In this stage, the Bank will look whether the documents are properly filled up and signed.
This is the processing stage. The branch will prepare a Proposal. The proposal contains following relevant information-
- Borrowers name
- Business Address
- Factory address
- Country of Incorporation:
- Sector / Code:
- Operating CASA Acc No:
- Company Established:
- Relationship Since:
- GROUP POSITION
- PURPOSE OF REQUEST:
- PURPOSE OF FACILITY
- REPAYMENT SOURCE
- COLLATERAL / SECURITY/ SUPPORT
EBL charges the following two types of securities-
- Primary security
- Collateral security
The modes of charging securities usually followed by the branch are as follows—
Lien is the right to retain possession and not right of ownership Bank’s lien is general lien over its own financial obligation to clients. Property under line cannot be realized / sold and proceeds thereof cannot be appropriated without notice to the owner and sometimes without court’s order.
This is mortgage of movables by an agreement and here neither possession nor ownership is transferred. Hypothecated goods cannot be sold out/disposed of off without notice and court’s order. However, if a special power of attorney is taken in that case it can be disposed off without going to the court.
Pledge is the bailment of goods as security of payment of debt or performance or promise. Here, title and ownership are not transferred. Pledge goods may be sold out and proceeds thereof may be appropriated towards adjustment of Liability in case of failure of the borrower to repay of fulfill the terms and conditions. MBL has no charge of this type.
Mortgage is the transfer of interest of immovable property to secure the repayment of money advanced. Ownership remains with the mortgagor. In case of equitable mortgage, court’s order is necessary and in case of registered mortgage court’s order is not necessary for sale/disposal of the mortgaged property for adjustment of advance. the legal framework in this regard is the “Transfer of Property Act-1982”.
Assignment means the transfer of any existing or future right, properly or debt by one person to another.
Loan Classification, Provisioning Policies, Risk Management Framework & Recovery Strategies of Eastern Bank
When the borrower fail to pay installments timely, banks ranks the client in three classes according to the risk associated with the client. Any Loan if not repaid/renewed within the fixed expiry date for repayment will be treated as irregular just from the following day of the expiry date. This loan will be classified as
- Sub-standard: if it is kept irregular for 6 months or beyond but less than 9 months.
- Doubtful: if for 9 months or beyond but less than 12 months and
- Bad Debt: if for 12months or beyond.
Policy on loan classification of EBL:
The process of gradually upgrading the policies on loan classification and provisioning to the international level is going on. Measures have been taken to strengthen the credit discipline and the process of classification has been simplified. The following revised policies on loan classification and provisioning has been issued.
Categories of Loans: All loans and advances will be grouped into 3(Three) categories for the purpose of classification, namely
- Continuous Loan
- Demand Loan
- Fixed Term Loan and
Continuous Loan: – The loan Accounts in which transactions may be made within certain limit and have an expiry date for full adjustment will be treated as Continuous Loans. Examples are: CC, OD etc.
Demand Loan: The loans that become repayable on demand by the bank will be treated as Demand Loans. If any contingent or any other liabilities are turned to forced loans (i.e. without any prior approval as regular loan) those too will be treated as Demand Loans. Such as: Forced LIM, PAD, FBP, and IBP etc.
Fixed Term Loan: The loans, which are repayable within a specific time period under a specific repayment schedule, will be treated as Fixed Term Loans.
Basis for Loan Classification of EBL:
(a) Any Continuous Loan if not repaid/renewed within the fixed expiry date for repayment will be treated as irregular just from the following day of the expiry date. This loan will be classified as Sub-standard if it is kept irregular for 6 months or beyond but less than 9 months, as `Doubtful’ if for 9 months or beyond but less than 12 months and as `Bad-Debt’ if for 12months or beyond.
(b) Any Demand Loan will be considered as Sub-standard if it remains unpaid for 6 months or beyond but not over 9 months from the date of claim by the bank or from the date of forced creation of the loan; likewise the loan will be considered as Doubtful’ and Bad/loss if remains unpaid for 9 months or beyond but not over 12 months and for 12 months and beyond respectively.
(c) In case any installment(s) or part of installment(s) of a Fixed Term Loan is not repaid within the due date, the amount of unpaid installment(s) will be termed as `defaulted installment’.
(i) In case of Fixed Term Loans, which are repayable within maximum five years of time: –
If the amount of ‘defaulted installment is equal to or more than the “amount of installments” due within 6 months, the entire loan will be classified as “Sub-standard”.
If the amount of ‘defaulted installment is equal to or more than the amount of installments due within 12 months, the entire loan will be classified as ”Doubtful”.
If the amount of ‘defaulted installment is equal to or more than the ‘amount of installments due within 18 months, the entire loan will be classified as ”Bad & Loss.”
(ii) In case of Fixed Term Loans, which are repayable in more than five years of time: –
If the amount of `defaulted installment’ is equal to or more than the amount of installments due within 12 months, the entire loan will be classified as ‘Sub-standard.’
If the amount of `defaulted installment ‘ is equal to or more than the amount of installments due within 18 months, the entire loan will be classified as ‘Doubtful’.
If the amount of ‘defaulted installments ‘is equal to or more than the amount of installments due within 24 months, the entire loan will be classified as ‘Bad-Debt’.
Explanation: If any Fixed Term Loan is repayable at monthly installment, the amount of installments due within 6 months will be equal to the amount of summation of 6 monthly installments. Similarly, if repayable at quarterly installment, the amount of installment(s) due within 6 months will be equal to the amount of summation of 2 quarterly installments.
If any uncertainty or doubt arises in respect of recovery of any Continuous Loan, Demand Loan or Fixed Term Loan, the same will have to be classified on the basis of qualitative judgment be it classifiable or not on the basis of objective criteria.
If any situational changes occur in the stipulations in terms of which the loan was extended or if the capital of the borrower is impaired due to adverse conditions or if the value of the securities decreases or if the recovery of the loan becomes uncertain due to any other unfavorable situation, the loan will have to be classified on the basis of qualitative judgment.
Besides, if any loan is illogically or repeatedly re-scheduled or the norms of re-scheduling are violated or instances of (propensity to) frequently exceeding the loan-limit are noticed or legal action is lodged for recovery of the loan or the loan is extended without the approval of the proper authority, it will have to be classified on the basis of qualitative judgment.
Despite the probability of any loan’s being affected due to the reasons stated above or for any other reasons, if there exists any hope for change of the existing condition by resorting to proper steps, the loan, on the basis of qualitative judgment, will be classified as ‘Sub-standard ‘. But even if after resorting to proper steps, there exists no certainty of total recovery of the loan, it will be classified as ‘ Doubtful ‘ and even after exerting the all-out effort, there exists no chance of recovery, it will be classified as ‘ Bad-Debt ‘ on the basis of qualitative judgment.
The concerned bank will classify on the basis of qualitative judgment and can declassify the loans if qualitative improvement does occur.
But if any loan is classified by the Inspection Team of Bangladesh Bank, the same can be declassified with the approval of the Board of Directors of the bank. However, before placing such case to the Board, the CEO and concerned branch manager shall have to certify that the conditions for declassification have been fulfilled.
Accounting of the interest of classified loans of EBL:
If any loan or advance is classified as ‘Sub-standard’ and ‘Doubtful’, interest can be charged in the loan account; but the interest thus charged cannot be transferred to Income account. The total interest charged in the ‘Sub-standard’ and ‘Doubtful’ loan accounts will have to be preserved in the ‘Interest Suspense’ account.
As soon as any loan or advance is classified as ‘Bad Debt’, charging of interest in the same account will cease. In case of filing a law-suit for recovery of such loan, interest for the period till filing of the suit can be charged in the loan account in order to file the same for the amount of principal plus interest. But interest thus charged in the loan account has to be preserved in the ‘Interest Suspense ‘ account. If any interest is charged in any ‘Bad-Debt’ account for any other special reason, the same will be preserved in the ‘Interest Suspense’ account.
If classified loan or part of it is recovered i.e., real deposit is affected in the loan account, first the interest charged and not charged is to be recovered from the said deposit and the principal to be adjusted afterwards.
A Continuous credit, Demand loan or a Term loan which will remain overdue for a period of 90 days or more, will be put into the “Special Mention Account” and interest accrued on such loan will be credited to Interest Suspense Account, instead of crediting the same to Income Account.
Classified Loans and advances of EBL:
As per Bangladesh Bank’s circulars the amount of three types of classified loans of EBL are shown by the following table
(Amount in take`000)
Table: Classified Loans and advances of EBL
If the data of the above table are plotted in the graph sheet, the following graph can be drawn for the classified loans of EBL.
The following chart shows the substandard loans and advances of last five years of EBL. From the graph we can see that the amounts of sub standard loans in the first 3 years are much higher. But in the last 2 years the bank was able to reduce a bulk amount because of its provisionary and recovery strategies and the bank is expecting that the reducing trend will continue for the following years.
Ratio of Classified loans of EBL:
(Amount in take`000)
|Year||Total outstanding loan||Amount of Classified loans||Ratio (%)|
From the chart we find a decreasing trend in the ratio of classified loans, which mean the amount of classified loans of EBL are decreasing over the years. It is possible because of the provisionary and recovery strategies of the bank. The bank is quite aware to hold the decreasing trend in the next coming year.
Risk management framework of EBL
INTRODUCTION TO RISK MANAGEMENT FRAMEWORK:
Comprehensive risk management is a core competence of Eastern Bank Ltd. We take a prudent and conservative approach to risk that is fully aligned with our long-term strategy. The risk framework combines centralized policy setting with broad oversight supported by risk execution and monitoring. It provides management with the ability to oversee the bank’s large and highly diversified portfolio effectively and efficiently. EBL’s risk management systems are designed to identify and analyze risks at an early stage, to set and monitor prudent limits, and to learn and evolve continuously to help us to face a volatile and rapidly-changing risk environment. In this way, EBL’s risk management adds value for the company’s shareholders.
The Board of Directors establishes the strategic risk philosophy and policies for Eastern Bank Ltd. They determine the risk policies, procedures and methodologies for measuring and monitoring risk as well as reputation risk issues. The Board of Directors-
- Set delegated authorities for management levels.
- Approve credit, market, and operational risk parameters associated with new Products.
- Approve risk on transactions whose value exceeds the amount of the authority delegated to management levels.
- Approve structured finance and complex transactions.
- Oversee the bank’s overall credit portfolio and review adequacy of provision.
CREDIT RISK MANAGEMENT
The main responsibilities of Credit Risk Management functions are:
- Oversee all credit, market and regulatory matters and ensure compliance with local laws.
- Approve risk transactions within their delegated authority and advise on credits which exceed such limits.
- Ensure implementation of credit facilities through an independent Credit Administration Function.
- Support the bank’s trading operations by monitoring and ensuring effective market risk exposure management.
- Implement review and control policies on all lending portfolios.
- Manage individual problem credits and monitor the distressed assets portfolio within EBL’s risk parameters.
- Recommend provisions for loan losses complying central banks rules and norms.
- Review lending programs and provide recommendations for approval.
- Ensure compliance with EBL’s Corporate Values and Business Principles.
ASSET AND LIABILITY RISK MANAGEMENT
ALCO is responsible for protecting the bank’s earnings and capital position against adverse interest rate and currency movements in its trading portfolios, as well as managing the bank’s longer-term liquidity profile. Members of the ALCO are drawn from the Business, Finance and Risk.
- ALCO particularly focus on Interest rate risk, Currency risk & Liquidity risk.
- They work on managing the company’s capital structure i.e. the balance sheet risk.
- They set standards and policies for transfer pricing for inter Business Unit transactions, manages the corporate investment portfolio of the bank and are responsible for setting overall Value-at-Risk (VaR) limits.
OPERATIONAL RISK MANAGEMENT
Operational risk is the risk of losses resulting from inadequate or failed internal processes, human behavior and systems or from external events. This risk includes operational risk events such as IT problems, shortcomings in the organizational structure, and lapses in internal controls, human errors, fraud, and external threats.
EBL has instituted an Operational Risk Policy and Framework, which together outline tasks and responsibilities at each organizational level.
- The Chief Operating Officer is responsible for establishing policies and standards on operational risk and oversees the ORM activities throughout EBL.
- Finance takes responsibility for the reliability and accuracy of the financial and accounting data and monitor compliance to budget and fiscal aspects of transactions.
- Internal Control ensures that all staff of EBL adheres to the regulations applicable to the business and reviews and inspects departments for internal controls.
MANAGEMENT OF PROGRAMMED LENDING
Program lending refers to credit that is approved under a Product Program Guideline (PPG) and managed on a portfolio basis. When providing credit to consumers and certain small and medium-sized enterprises, EBL relies on the Product Program process for credit approval and risk management.
The Business Unit prepares a Product Program Guideline to apply for approval to offer a certain credit product. The PPG must specify the target customers or customer segment and should contain standard risk acceptance criteria for evaluating and approving individual transactions.
The Board of Directors approves Product Program after getting vetted and recommended by Management committee. Under an approved PPG, the authority level to approve individual credit transactions is delegated to authorized individuals.
Credit initiation, account maintenance and collection decisions may be based on the objective application of eligibility criteria together with other guidelines described in Risk management guideline of the approved Product Program or on credit scoring. The portfolio performance databases are maintained by the businesses to help in portfolio control.
EBL’s loan portfolio, its composition and growth in 2005 was constrained by competitive market conditions. Clients have been conservative in their financial strategies and restrained in their borrowing, resulting in a relatively lower utilization of credit facilities. Additionally, the strengthening of the USD has limiting impact on growth in BDT portfolios. EBL’s Loan portfolio is highly diversified and evenly distributed over 14 different industry segments.
In 2005, Corporate Clients continued to be the largest among BUs holding approximately 88.8% of total loans outstanding while consumer was second with 9.6%, and standing of SME was 3.6%.
Eastern Banks Loan provisioning policy is guided by the central banks rules and policies as proposed time to time. The provisioning policies applicable as at 31 Dec 2005 were as follows:
|Small & Medium||2||90 Days||5||180D||20||270D||50||365D||100|
|All other||1||90 Days||5||180D||20||270D||50||365D||100|
General Provisioning for these products are carried out on a portfolio basis. However specific provision is determined by the bank’s loss experience of a particular client. The Central Banks Loan Loss Provision Guidelines recommends in general, when interest or principal on a consumer loan is overdue for 90 days or more, any further accrual of interest is suspended and such loans are then classified as non accrual.
Doubtful and non-performing loans are classified as doubtful as soon as there is evidence about the borrower’s lack of ability to meet its payment obligations to the bank in accordance with the original contractual terms. Where deemed necessary, an allowance for loan losses is determined on a per item basis, taking into account the value of the collateral.
These policies are kept under constant review and are adjusted to reflect (among other things) the bank’s actual loss experience and changes in legislation. Bank’s dedicated credit committees or its authorized individuals review the status of its corporate and commercial clients, at least once in a year, to whom it grants credits.
Additionally, the bank’s credit officers continually monitor the quality of loans. Should the quality of a loan or the borrower’s financial strength deteriorate to the extent that doubts arise over the borrower’s ability to repay the loan, management of the relationship is transferred to Special Asset Management Unit (SAMU). After making an assessment of the specific provision that should be made taking into account the value of collateral, CRM reviews specific provisions on the portfolio at the close of each quarterly reporting period, to ensure their adequacy.
NON-PERFORMING LOANS STATUS:
Non-performing loans are doubtful loans that are placed on a non-accrual basis. This means that the contractual interest is no longer recognized as income. Any asset or exposure in the loans and advances portfolio that bears an impairment loss on principal or interest is defined as non-performing.
The volume of non-performing loans decreased to Taka 960.9 million from Taka 1077.3 million in 2004 reflecting the improved quality of the credit portfolio. The ratio of non-performing loans stood at 5.41% as at 31/12/2005 compared to 7.19% in 2004.
Signs for Classification:
First and foremost requirement for any credit managers is to identify a problem credit in its earliest stages by recognizing the sings of deterioration. Such sings include but not limited to the following:
- Non-payment of interest or principal or both on due dates or past dues beyond a reasonable period or recurring past dues.
- In case of Overdraft no movement in the account beyond a reasonable period.
- Deterioration in financial condition of the client, as gathered from client’s latest financial statement.
- A shortfall in collateral coverage, particularly if the collateral was a key factor in the decision-making.
- Death or withdrawal of key owner(s) or management personnel.
- Company filing for bankruptcy or voluntary dissolution.
- Adverse market report about the company itself or its principal owners.
Steps to follow for Classification:
Steps to follow in such situations would be:
- Recheck the account, for all outstanding, including any outstanding in allied or sister company or in owner’s or partners’ or directors personal names.
- Thoroughly review loan documentation to confirm, “We have what we need”, documents are in proper from, properly executed and current (i.e. not time barred).
- If possible take current market value of the securities according to liquidation basis. And take a close look at the assets and liabilities to determine who has the prior right on those assets.
- If Grantors are involved, look closely at the net worth statement and send demand notice.
- Once the account is classified Sub-Standard, credit lines must be frozen.
For the purpose of determining the “Classified” status of an account, following guidelines are to be observed
The process of classification of an account will start with strict application of the risk rating assessment that is
- Bad or Loss
However unpaid interest or Principal or Expired Limit for a period of 180 days or more or recurring past dues will remain the most significant rules for classification.
Up-Down Grading Classification:
After classification the client has only two options in hand – either payoff the whole or partial liabilities and erase or down grade the name from the classified list. Or the client can refuse to pay and up grade their position in the classification list.
Special Asset Management Department [SAMD]:
EBL has a special department called SAMD who are responsible for all accounts classified in the bank’s portfolio. Actually they have work like CID officers. However SAMD’s responsibility will cover the areas of
- Monitoring and controlling the classified accounts through monthly reporting and quarterly review.
- Actively follow the borrowers for recovery.
- Negotiate and reschedule the debts.
- If the client don’t utilize the new offer than it is the SAMD’s responsibility to file suit against the client.
- SAMD will also prepare a Consolidated Report of all bad loans written-off on a quarterly basis.
What are the main reasons behind classification?
New Banker or lacking of experience.
Most of the time bankers have to rely on the documents provided on the client. But what is the purity of these data. Although the CA firm certifies the dates but financial jugulating is practicing around the world.
- Client’s over confidence about the project.
- Change in National and International Political scenery.
- Sometimes borrower talks about some other repayment source out of the proposed project but they don’t keep the source as security to the bank.
- Sometimes other than land or building banks also keep furniture and machinery as security. Later on when bank come to sell those, they found that the market value of those assets is much lesser than the book value.
- Sometimes bankers don’t go through the financial figures properly.
- Most of the cases clients have done some financial jugulating on their data.
- Sometimes Clint caught by some unavoidable circumstances like- ship sink.
- Sometimes bank don’t take appropriate security from the client or granter.
- Sometimes bank don’t put concentration about the insurance.
- Most of the cases the bankers fail to forecast the future business condition of the clients.
What’s wrong with Provision?
Although provisioning is associated with classified loans but it has a positive effect on the banks. The Income Statement shows net profit after deduction of provisioning fund. As a result tax goes down. But the most important thing is, it doesn’t affect the dividend. Although naturally banks pay dividends from net profit but some times they pay dividends from previous retained earnings. Moreover banks don’t keep money as idle fund for provisioning. Money circulates among the operations. They just show this fund to cover actual loss. So the bottom line is nothing is wrong to provision though it is associated with classified loans.
EBL is different in Recovery:
EBL has a department called Special Asset Management Department. The task of this department is to collect money from the classified clients. But in the other banks the Branch Manager does this job. Other than that the recovery criteria are more or less same for the banks. At the very beginning they send reminder letter. Then they send letter to inform them that they (bank) are going to sue against the client. Finally the banks sue against the client.
Why Recovery takes so much time:
Only because of existing rules and regulation recovery is a time consuming procedure. I think an example will make this thing clear. Let, Mr. X took loan from Y bank by giving a land as registered mortgage and become bad. Now bank cannot sell the land without the permission court though the land was as registered mortgage to bank. So bank has to sue against Mr. X and court send notice to Mr. X. But Mr. X can delay his coming by saying he is sick and asking for more time. Court gives new date to settle the matter. Then on new date a person come to the court saying that he is the brother of the client and the land is their father’s property. And most importantly, client didn’t notify him before give the land to the bank. So court asks him to prove his claim. Finally, if court gives injunction in favor of bank, they face problem to sell the land. Because client put mussel-men protect the land from bank. Moreover people are not interested buy land on occasion from court. Finally the interesting thing is most of the time the same client but the land in anther name in lower price.
EBL is presently concentrating on “ Blue Chip” status of Bangladesh to reduce the risk in credit advance. I feel this attitude of EBL is contrary to the mission of entrepreneurial development required by Bangladesh. So, they should concentrate more on new entrepreneurs than only on “ blue chip status”
To reduce the credit risk of relatively large credits, the EBL should dispute or post a well trained executive to each organization
Islamic banking is a process of profit/loss sharing. So, I feel that EBL should think of opening a Islamic banking Division to mitigate the full burden of credit risk.
To make their product highly visible and attract genuine entrepreneurs, the EBL should put more effort on various mode of advertisement
Restructuring has resulted in reduction of classified loans. So, they should further study to find out if there is any further scope of modification of structures and strategies in loan evaluation and approval.
Before sanctioning credit facility bank should check about documents “whether They have what they need”.
Credit officer should go through the feasibility study properly about the project.
They should not relay on the data provided by the client. They should judge the validity of those figurers by checking client’s account books.
Management should give more authority to the credit officers to make them responsible.
Bank should give priority to the limited companies rather than proprietorship business because after the death of any proprietor, bank cannot sue for the asset of the proprietor. The assets distributed among the family members. It does not matter whether the assets was keep as security to the bank or not.
The lending function of a bank needs to add value to the bank. The lending function comprises organizations, funding, monitoring and servicing of loan. This process is an ongoing one that beings when a loan application is made and screened and continues until the loan is repaid. Now unpaid loans are incomplete transactions for lenders. These incomplete transactions will not add rather destroy value. The primary danger in granting loan or credit is the possibility that the transaction may remain incomplete or in other words, the borrower may not repay the loan on a timely basis, which is properly known as credit risk or default the loan on a timely basis, which is properly known as credit risk or default risk. Proper and prudent management of default risk is the way to create value in the lending function. Excessive credit risk manifests itself in the form of excessive non-performing loans and loan loss provisions, which destroy bank value. Therefore, the value creation objective on the part of banks can be achieved by emphasizing the prevention of potential non-performing loans and identification and resolution of existing problem loans.
The question of loan default is related with (non) recovery / repayment of loans. When a borrower cannot repay interest and/or installment on a loan after it has become due, then it is qualified as default loan or non-performing loan. It is known as non-performing, because the loan cases to perform or generate income for the bank. The default/non-performing loan is not a “uni-class”, rather a “multi-class” concept. It implies that the default/non-performing loans can be classified into different groups usually based on the “length of overdue” of the said loans. The international standard classification terminologies are sub-standard, doubtful and bad/loss loans. Since 1980s, the central banks of the developing world followed the practices of the developed countries, have adopted the “prudential norms for asset classification” with a view to ensure transparency and “quality” of the loan portfolio of the banks.
The prudential guidelines also call for making adequate “provisions” against classified loans in order to protect the financial health of the banks. The economic implications of the non-performing / default loans are not only stoppage of creating new loans but also the erosion of banks profitability, liquidity and solvency, which might sometimes lead towards collapse of the banking financial system. It has, therefore become essential for policy makers to study the loan default scenario of the banking sector on a routine basis for estimating classified loan, making appropriate provisioning, adopting effective recovery strategy and thus ensuring soundness and efficiency of the banking sector.